Abstract:An extensive network of tunnels has recently been constructed in the Qinling Mountains. Characterized by high and steep terrain, this network has led to frequent traffic accidents. To address this issue, this paper introduces the theory of resilience into the evaluation system of safety systems during the operation period of highway tunnel groups. Based on this, this paper establishes a resilience evaluation index system for the operation safety system of highway tunnel groups, including a human system, vehicle system, and road system. To address both qualitative and quantitative issues concerning the indicators, this paper employs the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and entropy weight method to combine and assign weights to the resilience evaluation indicators. Subsequently, the cloud model method is utilized to quantify the level of resilience of the highway tunnel group safety system during the operation period. The study results unveiled the patterns of traffic accidents within the Qinling Tunnel Group from the perspectives of vehicle, road, and human factors. The final weight allocation reveals that the road system has the highest proportion, exerting the greatest influence as a primary level index. Moreover, by taking the Qinling Tunnel Group on the Xihan Expressway as an engineering example, the resilience level of the case project was analyzed and obtained. Proposals for enhancing resilience were put forth, taking into account the project's unique attributes, encompassing adaptability, resistance, and recovery. Overall, this study validates the feasibility and reliability of the proposed method for assessing the resilience of highway networks, offering empirical support for transportation administrators in the implementation of resilience-enhancing strategies.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems Addressed by the Paper
The paper primarily aims to address the issue of resilience assessment of the safety system for the Qinling tunnel group during its operation period. Specifically, by introducing resilience theory, the paper constructs a comprehensive evaluation index system to assess the safety system of highway tunnel groups during operation. This system includes factors from three aspects: human, vehicle, and road. It combines the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and the entropy weight method to assign weights to the indicators and uses the cloud model method to quantify the resilience level of the tunnel group safety system.
### Summary of Specific Content
1. **Background Introduction**:
- A large number of tunnels have been built in the Qinling Mountains in recent years, but due to the complex terrain, traffic accidents are frequent.
- This paper introduces resilience theory into the safety system assessment of highway tunnel groups during the operation period and establishes a resilience evaluation index system that includes three subsystems: human, vehicle, and road.
2. **Data Foundation and Statistics**:
- The study collected traffic accident data of the Qinling tunnel group from 2015 to 2021 and conducted detailed statistical analysis.
- The analysis results show that traffic accidents have certain regularities, especially occurring most frequently between 8 AM and 6 PM, accounting for 60.1%; accidents mostly occur inside tunnels (74.6%), followed by tunnel entrances and exits (25.4%). Rear-end collisions account for 58.8% of total accidents, and single-vehicle accidents (such as rollovers and wall collisions) account for 27.8%.
3. **Risk Factor Analysis**:
- **Human Factors**: Driver behavior is the main risk factor, with speeding accounting for the highest proportion (37.3%), followed by overloading (22.8%), illegal overtaking (20.9%), and fatigued driving (13.5%).
- **Vehicle Factors**: Large trucks and cars are the main types of accident vehicles, accounting for 41.7% and 32.2% respectively; the accident rate increases with the increase in traffic flow.
- **Road Factors**: The proportion of accidents in curved sections inside tunnels is relatively high (95.4%), and poor road conditions significantly increase the accident rate.
4. **Resilience Concept Model and Evaluation Index System**:
- The paper proposes a resilience concept model for the safety system of highway tunnel groups during operation and constructs an evaluation system based on this model, which includes eight indicators.
- The indicators include driving behavior, driving time, vehicle type, traffic flow, tunnel conditions, tunnel spacing, road conditions, and lateral alignment.
Through the above research, the paper verifies the feasibility and reliability of the proposed method in assessing the resilience of highway networks, providing empirical support for transportation management departments.