Abstract:Abstract Background Many animals appear to preferentially renest in proximity to a site they previously occupied. Evidence of nest fidelity is often inferred from a right skewed distribution of distances between the nests of individuals that breed in two consecutive reproduction episodes, where many individuals nest some arbitrarily close distance to their prior nest and others, in the extended right tail of the distribution, nest far from the nest they previously occupied. Because right skewed distributions of inter-nest distances can arise even when individuals choose nest locations randomly, however, such inferences are prone to error. The importance of null models—used to generate patterns of individual inter-nest distances by processes that do not involve site attachment—for inferences about site fidelity has been known for decades but is still often unappreciated or ignored. Methods The right skewed distributions of inter-nest distances observed in two earlier studies of male smallmouth bass ( Micropterus dolomieu ) suggest prima facie that males exhibit nest site fidelity between annual reproduction episodes, but patterns of inter-nest distances have yet to be compared to an adequate null model. Here, we evaluate the nest site fidelity of marked male M . dolomieu in a decade-long dataset, where we apply a randomization procedure based on the rencontre probability problem to generate null models. Eight observed distributions of individual, annual inter-nest distances are compared to a year-specific null model to determine whether random processes are sufficient to explain the observed distributions of inter-nest distances. Results Through contrasts between observed annual inter-nest distances and results derived from null models that imposed realistic constraints on behavior, we show that some males were undoubtedly nest-site faithful. To reinforce the utility of null models and to make these kinds of models more accessible, we also provide a supplemental tutorial. The tutorial illustrates how random site choices, subject to common ecological and behavioral constraints, and even how distance is measured, can produce patterns of inter-nest distances that falsely imply nest site fidelity, or a lack of fidelity. The R code needed to reproduce these null models is included. The inference errors evident in our examples generalize to other forms of site fidelity, such as the apparent patch fidelity of certain sea bird foragers. Conclusions The comparisons of observed distributions of inter-nest distances with those generated by null models imply that, as suggested in prior studies, male M . dolomieu indeed exhibit annual nest site fidelity. Procedures like those we apply are necessary first steps in analyses when distributions of distances between the nests of individuals in consecutive reproduction episodes are used to infer nest-site fidelity. Why male M. dolomieu are site faithful is a question yet to be answered.

Nest-use pattern of fluvial goby (Rhinogobius flumineus) in relation to the presence or absence of amphidromous congener: a case study of two rivers in southern central Honshu, Japan

Intra-specific variations of egg size, clutch size and larval survival relatedto maternal size in amphidromous Rhinogobius goby

Spatial distribution of spawning redds and larvae of Rhinogobius flumineus in relation to hydrogeomorphological characteristics in Kamo River, Japan

Fluctuating population density of the goby Lubricogobius exiguus during the breeding season with artificial nests at Oto Beach, Kagoshima, southern Japan

The relative importance of substrate conditions as microhabitat determinants of a riverine benthic goby, Rhinogobius sp. OR (orange form) in runs

Null models confirm nest site fidelity by male smallmouth bass, Micropterus dolomieu

Growth and morphological development of laboratory-reared larval and juvenile Rhinogobius flumineus (Perciformes: Gobiidae)

Brooding fathers actively consume viable embryos to take up nutrients in a monogamous syngnathid fish

Female mate choice for male size in a freshwater goby under experimental conditions eliminating inter-male interference

Genetic variability of Myxobolus nagaraensis (Bivalvulida: Myxobolidae) infecting freshwater gobies Rhinogobius Gill 1859 (Gobiiformes: Oxudercidae) from rivers in Japan

Parentage of Overlapping Offspring of an Arboreal-Breeding Frog with No Nest Defense: Implications for Nest Site Selection and Reproductive Strategy

Maternal control of sex ratio in Rana rugosa: evidence from DNA sexing

Facultative nesting in Rhinella spinulosa (Anura: Bufonidae): strategy to avoid dehydration of offspring

Phenotypic Consequences of Maternally Selected Nests: a Cross-Fostering Experiment in a Desert Lizard.

Growth and diet of the invasive mosquitofish Gambusia affinis in lotic and lentic habitats in Japan

Intraguild predation of water scorpion Laccotrephes japonensis (Nepidae: Heteroptera)

Estimation of tributary–mainstem migration of freshwater fishes by Sr isotope analysis of otoliths

Characterization of the reproductive strategy of invasive Round Goby (Neogobius melanostomus) in the Upper Danube River

Patterns of genomic divergence and introgression between Japanese stickleback species with overlapping breeding habitats

Asymmetric competition for habitats between the temperate Japanese eel Anguilla japonica and the tropical Indo-Pacific eel A. marmorata

Contrasting interspecific hybridization patterns in two goby groups radiating in divergent freshwater habitats