Ibuprofen Compared to Acetazolamide for the Prevention of Acute Mountain Sickness: A Randomized Placebo-Controlled Trial
Srinivasa Bhattachar,Vineet K Malhotra,Uday Yanamandra,Surinderpal Singh,Gaurav Sikri,Seema Patrikar,Atul Kotwal
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.55998
2024-03-12
Cureus
Abstract:Introduction: Acetazolamide is recommended for the prevention of acute mountain sickness (AMS); however, its use is limited in some areas because of side effects. Previous studies report ibuprofen to be similar to or slightly inferior to acetazolamide. This randomized, triple-blinded, parallel-group, placebo-controlled trial was designed to compare ibuprofen with acetazolamide for the prevention of AMS. Methods: Four hundred forty-three healthy Asian Indian men with a mean age of 29 (range: 20-49) years were randomized into three groups A, B, and P at 350m (SL). Acetazolamide (A): 85 mg; ibuprofen (B): 600 mg; or placebo (P): calcium carbonate was administered thrice daily, starting one day prior and continuing for three days after arrival at 3500m (HA). Participants were evaluated for AMS using the Lake Louise Questionnaire and for pulse, BP, SpO2, and respiratory rate twice daily for the first two days during rest and once a day for days three to six at HA. Results: Of the 443 participants recruited at SL, 139 could not be airlifted due to logistical limitations, and 304 were available for follow-up at HA. Among these, 254 had ascended as per protocol. By intent to treat (IT) (N = 304; A = 99, B = 102, P = 103), the incidence of AMS (LLQS>/=3) was 12%, 5%, and 13%, and the incidence of severe AMS was 1%, 2%, and 6%, in groups A, B, and P, respectively. Using per protocol analysis (PP) (N = 254; A = 83, B = 87, P = 84), the incidence of AMS was 12%, 6%, and 13% in groups A, B, and P, respectively. The relative risk for developing AMS vs. placebo was A-0.96 (CI:0.46-2.0, p=0.91), B-0.39 (CI:0.14-1.04, p=0.06), A-0.94 (CI:0.42-2.1, p=0.88), and B-0.45 (0.16-1.24, p=0.12) by IT and PP, respectively. Conclusion: Ibuprofen is effective in males for the prevention of AMS with rapid ascent to 3500 m-rest for the first two days. Acetazolamide was superior to ibuprofen in the prevention of moderate-to-severe AMS.