Abstract:One speech sound can be associated with multiple meanings through iconicity, indexicality, and/or systematicity. It was not until recently that this “pluripotentiality” of sound symbolism attracted serious attention, and it remains uninvestigated how pluripotentiality may arise. In the current study, Japanese, Korean, Mandarin, and English speakers rated unfamiliar jewel names on three semantic scales: size, brightness, and hardness. The results showed language-specific and cross-linguistically shared pluripotential sound symbolism. Japanese speakers associated voiced stops with large and dark jewels, whereas Mandarin speakers associated [i] with small and bright jewels. Japanese, Mandarin, and English speakers also associated lip rounding with darkness and softness. These sound-symbolic meanings are unlikely to be obtained through metaphorical or metonymical extension, nor are they reported to colexify. Notably, in a purely semantic network without the mediation of lip rounding, softness can instead be associated with brightness, as illustrated by synesthetic metaphors such as yawaraka-na hizashi /jawaɾakanaçizaɕi/ “a gentle (lit. soft) sunshine” in Japanese. These findings suggest that the semantic networks of sound symbolism may not coincide with those of metaphor or metonymy. The current study summarizes the findings in the form of (phono)semantic maps to facilitate cross-linguistic comparisons of pluripotential sound symbolism.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the pluripotentiality in sound symbolism, that is, a phoneme can be associated with multiple different meanings. Specifically, through experimental design, the researchers explored the perception of sound symbolism in the three semantic dimensions of size, brightness and hardness for unfamiliar jewelry names in four languages: Japanese, Korean, Mandarin and English. The main objectives of the study are:
1. **Identify cross - language - shared sound symbolism patterns**: Investigate whether there is consistency among speakers of different languages in the association between specific phonemes and multiple meanings.
2. **Explore language - specific sound symbolism patterns**: Analyze whether there are unique sound symbolism perceptions in different languages that are different from other languages.
3. **Understand the sources of pluripotential sound symbolism**: Explore whether these pluripotential sound symbolisms are formed through abstract phoneme - meaning mapping, metaphorical extension or other mechanisms.
### Research Background
Sound symbolism refers to the iconic, indicative or systematic association between phonemes and meanings. In many cases, a phoneme can be associated with multiple meanings, a phenomenon known as "pluripotentiality". Although this phenomenon has long been recognized, its specific mechanisms and sources remain unclear. Researchers systematically explored this problem through non - word experiments.
### Experimental Methods
- **Participants**: Participants from four language backgrounds: Japanese, Korean, Mandarin and English.
- **Stimulus Materials**: 30 non - words composed of 5 vowels [i, e, u, o, ɑ] and 6 consonants [b, d, g, p, t, k], in the form of stressed vowel - consonant - vowel (VCV).
- **Experimental Procedure**: Participants completed the experiment online. Each non - word was followed by three 7 - point semantic differential scales to evaluate the size, brightness and hardness of the jewelry respectively.
### Main Findings
- **Size**: In all languages, non - front vowels, low vowels and rounded vowels tend to be associated with larger images. Japanese speakers' perception of the size of voiceless consonants is particularly obvious.
- **Brightness**: Except for Korean, non - front vowels in all languages tend to be rated as darker. Rounded vowels appear darker in all languages.
- **Hardness**: Rounded vowels are rated as softer in all languages. Bilabial stops are also softer than alveolar stops in all languages. Interestingly, palatal stops are considered harder in Japanese and Mandarin, but relatively softer in Korean and English.
### Discussion
- **Cross - language - shared sound symbolism**: Front vowels [i, e] are associated with small jewelry, rounded vowels [u] are associated with dark jewelry, and the softness of rounded vowels is more common in multiple languages.
- **Language - specific sound symbolism**: Japanese speakers are sensitive to consonant voicing, Mandarin speakers are sensitive to the smallness of rounded vowels, and Korean speakers are sensitive to the hardness of palatal stops.
- **Sources of pluripotential sound symbolism**: Pluripotential sound symbolisms may be formed through abstract phoneme - meaning mapping, metaphorical extension or other mechanisms. For example, the darkness and softness of rounded vowels may be the result of the combined action of low - frequency sounds and the softness of the lips.
In conclusion, through cross - language experiments, this study reveals the pluripotentiality of sound symbolism and the cognitive mechanisms behind it, providing a new perspective for further understanding of sound symbolism.