Abstract:The development and utilization of underground spaces can ease the shortage of urban land resources, ensure urban safety, and improve the urban ecological environment. Human overall comfort and work efficiency in underground spaces are affected by several environmental factors, such as thermal, acoustic, and lighting. Owing to the particularities of an underground space at any given location, the guarantee of a comfortable indoor environment is different from that in aboveground buildings. Based on the thermal, acoustic, and illumination characteristics of an underground space, the main differences between underground spaces and aboveground buildings, limitations of current standards/codes, and imperfections of internal environmental evaluation indicators are summarized and analyzed, and human comfort and work efficiency in terms of one-way and three-way interactions are discussed based on the literature published since 2000. The findings reveal that the current standards/codes for underground spaces mainly refer to aboveground buildings. Where the parameter index is single, there exists a large difference between the underground environment and the design standard, and there is no evaluation index for human comfort in underground spaces. In the existing research, two methods have been adopted: field surveys and climate room experiments. These have mainly focused on the effects of thermal, acoustic, and lighting environment unidirectional control on personnel comfort, while only a few studies have been conducted on work efficiency. Research on the three-directional interactions involving thermal, acoustic, and lighting environments in underground spaces is lacking. The creation of a microenvironment based on local cooling and heating, and the technologies generated under the concepts of imitating the ground environment, imitating the natural environments, and thermal–acoustic–light coordinated control are expected to play important roles in the construction of underground space environments in the future, and lay the foundation for the construction of an ecological environment system in underground spaces.

Sustainable design for underground environments in modern cities

Passive Ventilation for Sustainable Underground Environments from Traditional Underground Buildings and Modern Multiscale Spaces

A two-level optimisation approach for underground natural ventilation based on CFD and building energy simulations

Working in Underground Spaces: Architectural Parameters, Perceptions and Thermal Comfort Measurements

Assessment of Energy Recovery Potential in Urban Underground Utility Tunnels: A Case Study

A network model for natural ventilation simulation in deep buried underground structures

Integrated design for underground space environment control of subway stations with atriums using piston ventilation

Parameter optimisation of the ventilation system for an underground power space using a hybrid model

Study on ventilation effect for a large space in an underground hydropower station

An innovative ventilation system using piston wind for the thermal environment in Shanghai subway station

Natural Ventilation of Underground Shelters to Improve Indoor Thermal and Moisture Environments in the Various Climates of China

Thermal performance of a novel underground energy migration system for greenhouse

Feasibility and climate adaption of shallow geothermally driven direct ventilation

A Review of Ventilation and Environmental Control of Underground Spaces

The Formation of Multi-Steady-states of Buoyancy Ventilation in Underground Building

Heat and Humidity Transport Analysis Inside a Special Underground Building

New framework of low-carbon city development of China: Underground space based integrated energy systems

Effect of Thermal, Acoustic, and Lighting Environment in Underground Space on Human Comfort and Work Efficiency: A Review

The Thermal-Wet Environment Testing and Analysis of Underground Plant Traffic Tunnel

A study of the correlation between summer outdoor meteorological parameters and hydropower station ventilation schemes

Study of Natural Ventilation Potential and Performance for the Undergroun Utility Corridor Using Numerical Method