Abstract:We carry out a comparative analysis of inequality of opportunity (IOp) for long-run income in Denmark and the United States. We adopt a luck-egalitarian understanding of IOp, use high-quality administrative data, and rely on highly improved methods. These include novel identification assumptions that allow us to produce set estimates of IOp in the United States relative to Denmark rather than just lower-bound estimates of IOp in the two countries. There are five main results. First, with types based only on gender and parental income rank as the circumstances beyond people’s control, measured IOp for income is high in the United States and far from negligible in Denmark: before taxes and transfers, the lower-bound Gini coefficients for individual earnings and family income opportunities are in the 0.21-024 range in the United States and in the 0.08–0.12 range in Denmark. Second, the tax system and the welfare state reduce measured IOp in both countries, but they do so by more than twice as much in Denmark. Third, our analyses in terms of disposable family income per adult—which factor in taxes and transfers and purge the effect of the association between parental income and the probability of marriage—entail that there is more IOp for income in the United States than overall income inequality in Denmark. Fourth, IOp for income is substantially higher in the United States than in Denmark. With opportunities defined in terms of disposable family income per adult, IOp is at the very least 68 percent higher in the United States, and this result is very robust to the inequality index employed in the analysis. Fifth, our lower-bound estimates of the unfair inequality as a share of overall inequality are much larger in both countries than typically reported for advanced economies. When we account for race and ethnicity as circumstances beyond people’s control (in addition to gender and parental income), our lower-bound estimate of that share for the U.S. reaches almost 58 percent. We conclude that the distribution of economic opportunities—and not just of economic outcomes—is substantially less unequal in Denmark than in the U.S., and that a very large share of U.S. income inequality may be tracked back to circumstances beyond people’s control.

New estimates for inequality of opportunity in Europe using elastic net algorithms

Educational Inequality of Opportunity and Mobility in Europe

Are there inequality spillovers? Evidence through a modified inequality measure and European dynamics of inequality

The European Union and Material Deprivation: Measuring the Evolution of Inequalities over the 2000s

A new approach for measuring poverty or social exclusion reduction in European NUTS 2 regions

Inequality and poverty in Spain: Insights from a regional convergence analysis

Labour market prospects of young adults in Europe: differential effects of social origin during the Great Recession

Winners and losers from occupational segregation across Europe: the role of gender and migration status

Using panel data clustering regression analysis to revisit income inequalities in the European Union

To be or not to be (employed): two decades of fluctuating earnings and income inequality in Spain

Inequality trends in a slow‐growing economy: Italy, 1990–2020

Income inequality and foregone medical care in Europe during The Great Recession: multilevel analyses of EU-SILC surveys 2008-2013

Club Convergence in the Eurozone: A Look at Inequality Dynamics

Assessing the Impact of ICT Sector on Sustainable Development in the European Union: An Empirical Analysis Using Panel Data

Machine Learning Analysis of the Impact of Increasing the Minimum Wage on Income Inequality in Spain from 2001 to 2021

Educational Status as a Mediator of Intergenerational Social Mobility in Europe: A Positional Analysis Approach

Predictors of Economic Outcomes among Romanian Youth: The Influence of Education-An Empirical Approach Based on Elastic Net Regression

Inequality of Opportunity for Income in Denmark and the United States: A Comparison Based on Administrative Data

Educational Gaps in Latin American childhood: Regional Inequality in Learning Deprivation with Local Modulations

Using Machine Learning for NEETs and Sustainability Studies: Determining Best Machine Learning Algorithms

Unemployment expectations: A socio-demographic analysis of the effect of news