Vaccine hesitancy educational interventions for medical students: A systematic narrative review in western countries
Philip White Hugh Alberti Gill Rowlands Eugene Tang Dominique Gagnon Ève Dubé a Population Health Sciences Institute,Newcastle University Medical School,Newcastle upon Tyne,UKb School of Medical Education,Newcastle University Medical School,Newcastle upon Tyne,UKc Direction des risques biologiques,Institut national de santé publique du Québec,Quebec,Canadad Department of Anthropology,Laval University,Quebec,CanadaPhilip White is a National Institute of Health and Social Care Research (NIHR) Academic Clinical Fellow in General Practice based at Newcastle University. His research interests include vaccine hesitancy and medical education.Hugh Alberti is a General Practitioner and the Subdean for Primary and Community Care at Newcastle University. He leads a team of GP trainees and clinical teaching fellows focused on the development of educational initiatives and research projects within the realm of primary care. His research interests focus primarily on medical education,particularly within primary care and community settings.Gill Rowlands is a General Practitioner and a Professor in the Population Health Sciences Institute. Her main research interests are in the area of health inequalities,particularly the role of health literacy in health,and the role of GPs in identifying and addressing the problems faced by patients with lower health literacy. She founded the Health Literacy Group UK and has authored and co-authored over 70 publications in peer-reviewed journals,co-edited three health literacy textbooks and authored seven chapters in health literacy textbooks. She provides expert advice on health literacy to the Royal College of General Practice,NHS England,Belfast Healthy Cities,and the Health Service Executive (Ireland). She chairs the Health Literacy Global Working Group of the International Union of Health Promotion and Education.Eugene Tang is a NIHR Clinical Lecturer and General Practitioner based at Newcastle University. His research interests include post-stroke cognition,dementia,risk prediction modeling,and reducing inequalities in care.Dominique Gagnon is a scientific advisor in immunization at the Quebec National Institute of Public Health. She has over a decade of experience working on various vaccination-related projects,with a significant focus on addressing vaccine hesitancy.Eve Dubé is a medical anthropologist. She is a professor in the Department of Anthropology at Laval University in Quebec (Canada). She is also affiliated with the Quebec National Institute of Public Health and the Research Center of the CHU de Quebec-Université Laval. Most of her research focuses on the socio-cultural aspects of vaccination. She is also interested in vaccine hesitancy and doing various projects in that field. She was a member of the WHO working group on Vaccine Hesitancy. Since 2014,she is leading the Social Sciences and Humanities Network (SSHN) of the Canadian Immunization Research Network.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/21645515.2024.2397875
2024-09-27
Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics
Abstract:Physician recommendations can reduce vaccine hesitancy (VH) and improve uptake yet are often done poorly and can be improved by early-career training. We examined educational interventions for medical students in Western countries to explore what is being taught, identify effective elements, and review the quality of evidence. A mixed methods systematic narrative review, guided by the JBI framework, assessed the study quality using MERSQI and Cote & Turgeon frameworks. Data were extracted to analyze content and framing, with effectiveness graded using value-based judgment. Among the 33 studies with 30 unique interventions, effective studies used multiple methods grounded in educational theory to teach knowledge, skills, and attitudes. Most interventions reinforced a deficit-based approach (assuming VH stems from misinformation) which can be counterproductive. Effective interventions used hands-on, interactive methods emulating real practice, with short- and long-term follow-ups. Evidence-based approaches like motivational interviewing should frame interventions instead of the deficit model.
immunology,biotechnology & applied microbiology