Perceptions of Challenges Facing Rural Communities: An Importance–Performance Analysis

Jinyang Deng,David McGill,Douglas Arbogast

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3727/108354217x14888192562401

2017-06-12

Tourism Analysis

Abstract:Although several studies have focused on understanding attitudes held by local residents and/or other stakeholders toward the economic, environmental, and social/cultural impacts of tourism, very little research has examined the challenges and opportunities facing rural communities from the perspectives of multistakeholders. To fill this research void, this study uses the stakeholder theory as its foundation to examine challenges and opportunities facing the Appalachian Forest Heritage Area (AFHA) from the perspectives of both community leaders and residents using a modified, mean-centered importance–performance analysis (IPA). Results indicate that community leaders and residents are highly consistent in their perceived challenges facing the AFHA, with marketing, community leadership, and financial investment being identified by both groups as the most salient challenges that the AFHA needs to concentrate efforts on. Secondary priority identified by both groups relates to collaboration and partnership with tourism industry, the AFHA, and surrounding communities. The study also shows that the modified, mean-centered IPA is more effective, if judged by the iso-rating line, than either the data-centered approach or the scale-centered approach to identify priorities for improvement. Research implications and future research needs are also discussed.