Ranking Important Factors for Using Postoperative Chemotherapy in Non-Muscle Invasive Bladder Cancer: Conjoint Analysis Results From the Michigan Urological Surgery Improvement Collaborative (MUSIC)

Clint Cary,Yan Tong,Susan Linsell,Khurshid Ghani,David C. Miller,Michael Weiner,Michael O. Koch,Susan M. Perkins,Gregory Zimet
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/ju.0000000000002233
2021-09-25
Abstract:National and International guidelines recommend the use of one dose of intravesical chemotherapy immediately following surgery for non-muscle invasive bladder cancer, which is performed infrequently on a population level. We sought to understand the importance of potential environmental and clinical dimensions involved in the decision to offer this therapy. Urologists from the Michigan Urological Surgery Improvement Collaborative rated 8 distinct clinical vignettes involving patients with non-muscle invasive bladder cancer. A ratings-based conjoint analysis method was used to evaluate the clinical vignette responses. Each vignette included 4 clinical dimensions and 2 environmental dimensions, with each dimension consisting of 2 possible attributes. The relative importance of each attribute was derived from the regression model and ranked in order. A total of 58 urologists answered the clinical vignettes which represents >75% of MUSIC sites. The median age of urologists was 53, most were male, and median years in practice was 20 years post residency. An environmental attribute, having a recovery room protocol for instilling and disposing of the chemotherapy, ranked as the most influential attribute for giving postoperative chemotherapy (utility=8.6). The clinical attribute yielding the strongest preference for giving chemotherapy was tumor grade (utility=4.9). These preferences varied by different subgroups of urologists, particularly regarding the type of practice a urologist was in. This study demonstrates that urologists have clear preferences for when they offer postoperative immediate chemotherapy. Factors beyond just clinical variables play a role in this decision-making process such as the structure of the recovery room.
urology & nephrology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?