The Disruptive Innovation Impact of Supply and Demand Matching in Digital Platforms Using Fuzzy-Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis Methodology: Evidence from China

Shutong Jin,Haijun Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16020540

IF: 3.9

2024-01-08

Sustainability

Abstract:Practice shows that digital platforms could enhance disruptive innovation. Given that digital platforms have always encountered imbalance problems, this study intended to explore which factor configurations could promote disruptive innovation sustainably from the perspective of supply and demand matching. This study constructed a theoretical framework referring to the TOE framework. Based on 25 questionnaires from China, the fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) method was used to explore the configurations of disruptive innovations. This study found the following: (1) None of the five factors in the dimensions of technology, organization, or environment could constitute a necessary condition for enabling disruptive innovation alone. (2) There were four supply and demand matching configurations that could lead to highly disruptive innovation. Based on the homogeneous characteristics of the results, the four paths were divided into "technology-organization driven transition" types and "organization-environment collaborative transition" types. (3) Non-highly disruptive innovation included three specific configurations, all of which lacked the core conditions in technical and organizational dimensions, suggesting the importance of technical and organizational factors for disruptive innovation. This study provides guidance on supply and demand matching for platform enterprises to continuously create disruptive innovation. However, the data from China may limit the results' applicability to a more expansive setting.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What Problem Does This Paper Attempt to Solve?

This paper aims to explore which factor configurations can sustainably promote disruptive innovation on digital platforms from the perspective of supply-demand matching. Specifically, the study focuses on the following questions:

1. **Necessary Conditions**: From the perspective of supply-demand matching, what factors are necessary conditions for achieving disruptive innovation?
2. **Sufficient Condition Configurations**: What factor configurations can promote disruptive innovation?
3. **Path Formation**: How do these configurations form paths to disruptive innovation?

### Research Methods and Findings

- **Research Methods**: This study employs the fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) method and analyzes data from 25 questionnaires based in China.
- **Main Findings**:
- No single factor from the technological, organizational, or environmental dimensions alone constitutes a necessary condition for achieving disruptive innovation.
- There are four different supply-demand matching configurations that can lead to high levels of disruptive innovation. Based on the homogeneity characteristics of the results, these four paths are categorized into "technology-organization driven transformation" types and "organization-environment collaborative transformation" types.
- Non-highly disruptive innovations include three specific configurations that lack core conditions in the technological and organizational dimensions, indicating the importance of technological and organizational factors for achieving disruptive innovation.

### Contributions of the Paper

- **Methodological Contribution**: Enriches the application context of the fsQCA method by using it to explore factors of disruptive innovation on digital platforms.
- **Theoretical Contribution**: Embeds the logic of supply-demand matching into the configuration effects of disruptive innovation on digital platforms, based on Schumpeter's innovation theory.
- **Empirical Contribution**: Identifies different paths to achieving disruptive innovation based on the relationships between factors and their configuration effects.

Through the above research, the paper provides guidance for platform enterprises in terms of supply-demand matching to continuously create disruptive innovation. However, since the data source is limited to China, the research results may not be applicable to a broader context.