Whitening efficacy of activated charcoal-based products: a single-blind randomized controlled clinical trial

Edgar Pedreiro Ribeiro,Gabriela Torres Zanin,Andrey Emídio Gonçalves,Matheus Kury,Vanessa Cavalli,Ricardo Danil Guiraldo,Murilo Baena Lopes,Sandrine Bittencourt Berger
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdent.2024.104877
IF: 4.991
2024-02-05
Journal of Dentistry
Abstract:Objective This randomized controlled clinical trial evaluated the whitening efficacy, tooth sensitivity (TS), and volunteers' satisfaction following the use of activated charcoal powder and toothpaste. Methods Fifty-six volunteers were randomly allocated into 4 groups (n=14) according to a 14-day toothbrushing or whitening treatment with activated charcoal powder (ACPW), activated charcoal toothpaste (ACT), regular fluoridated toothpaste (RT), and 10% carbamide peroxide (CP). Objective (ΔE 00 ) and subjective (ΔSGU) color and whiteness index (ΔWI D ) changes were calculated. Patients self-reported the risk and intensity of TS using a visual analogue scale and the volunteer's satisfaction was determined by a questionnaire. Color assessments were analyzed by Kruskal-Wallis followed by Dwas-Steel-Crithlow-Fligner, and absolute TS risk and volunteer's satisfaction by Fisher exact test (p < 0.05). Results A CPW and ACT promoted similar effects in ΔE 00 , ΔSGU, and ΔWI D to that observed for RT. No significant difference was found in terms of TS risk intensity. TS risk became high after 7 and 14 days, with higher TS prevalence in CP. Volunteers reported that ACPW exhibited the lowest ease-of-use, comfort, and whitening satisfaction among groups (p<0.05). Conclusion Activated charcoal-based products presented a minor and unsatisfactory whitening effect while CP resulted in optimal tooth whitening and the highest level of satisfaction among volunteers. Risk was higher from 7 days onwards and was more pronounced in the CP. Clinical Relevance Based on the whitening effect and patient satisfaction, this controlled-randomized clinical evidence supports that the use of activated charcoal-based products should be discouraged.
dentistry, oral surgery & medicine
What problem does this paper attempt to address?