Abstract:Serology (the detection of antibodies formed by the host against an infecting pathogen) is frequently used to assess current infections and past exposure to specific pathogens. However, the presence of cross-reactivity among host antibodies in serological data makes it challenging to interpret the patterns and draw reliable conclusions about the infecting pathogen or strain. In our study, we use microscopic agglutination test (MAT) serological data from three host species [California sea lion ( Zalophus californianus ), island fox ( Urocyon littoralis ), and island spotted skunk ( Spilogale gracilis )] with confirmed infections to assess differences in cross-reactivity by host species and diagnostic laboratory. All host species are known to be infected with the same serovar of Leptospira interrogans . We find that absolute and relative antibody titer magnitudes vary systematically across host species and diagnostic laboratories. Despite being infected by the same Leptospira serovar, three host species exhibit different cross-reactivity profiles to a 5-serovar diagnostic panel. We also observe that the cross-reactive antibody titer against a non-infecting serovar can remain detectable after the antibody titer against the infecting serovar declines below detectable levels. Cross-reactivity in serological data makes interpretation difficult and can lead to common pitfalls. Our results show that the highest antibody titer is not a reliable indicator of infecting serovar and highlight an intriguing role of host species in shaping reactivity patterns. On the other side, seronegativity against a given serovar does not rule out that serovar as the cause of infection. We show that titer magnitudes can be influenced by both host species and diagnostic laboratory, indicating that efforts to interpret absolute titers (e.g., as indicators of recent infection) must be calibrated to the system under study. Thus, we implore scientists and health officials using serological data for surveillance to interpret the data with caution. Serology is frequently used for disease surveillance, especially in systems that are resource constrained or logistically challenging. Serological testing involves analyzing blood serum samples to detect antibodies with reactivity toward specific pathogens (or more generally, molecular antigens), with the goal of characterizing past exposure to those pathogens. However, these antibodies can be non-specific and may react against other related pathogens or strains–a phenomenon known as cross-reactivity. Interpretation of serological data exhibiting cross-reactivity is difficult and simplifying assumptions are often made (e.g., to interpret the strain that elicits the highest antibody titer level as the infecting pathogen strain). Our work shows that interpreting antibody data requires more nuance and more caution. Both absolute titers and relative reactivity against different strains can vary across host species and diagnostic laboratories, so it is essential to interpret these data in the appropriate context. These host species differences in antibody reactivity and cross-reactivity patterns make direct comparisons across species inadvisable.

Using ELISA to detect pathogen antibodies in wild mammal carcasses: a systematic literature review

Wildlife parasitology: sample collection and processing, diagnostic constraints, and methodological challenges in terrestrial carnivores

Diagnosis of tuberculosis in wildlife: a systematic review

Detection of selected pathogens in reproductive tissues of wild boars in the Campania region, southern Italy

Analysis of seroprevalence data on Hepatitis E virus and Toxoplasma gondii in wild ungulates for the assessment of human exposure to zoonotic meat-borne pathogens

Seroprevalence of infectious pathogens of zoonotic and veterinary importance in wild ruminants from Slovenia

Serological and molecular detection as well as typing of Leptospira spp. in foxes, raccoons, and other wild carnivores in North-Eastern Germany, 2021-2022

Performance of post-mortem diagnostic tests for tuberculosis in wild ungulates at low and high prevalence assessed using Bayesian latent class models

An integrative approach for profiling antibody responses in bats to human pathogens

A preliminary study of Salmonella, verocytotoxigenic Escherichia coli/Escherichia coli O157 and Campylobacter on four mixed farms

Toxoplasmosis in Zoo Animals: A Retrospective Pathology Review of 126 Cases

Navigating cross-reactivity and host species effects in a serological assay: A case study of the microscopic agglutination test for Leptospira serology

Metagenomic sequencing sheds light on microbes putatively associated with pneumonia-related fatalities of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus)

A non-invasive tool for assessing pathogen prevalence in koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) populations: detection of Chlamydia pecorum and koala retrovirus (KoRV) DNA in genetic material sourced from scats

Postmortem Sampling in Piglet Populations: Unveiling Specimens Accuracy for Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Detection

A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF RETROSPECTIVE MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY STUDIES ON CAPTIVE WILDLIFE SPECIES

Safety and Immunogenicity of Morbillivirus canis Vaccines for Domestic and Wild Animals: A Scoping Review

Diagnosis of botulism in mammals aided by toxin ELISA and C and D gene RT-PCRs with an emphasis on farm animals

Isolation of Multidrug-Resistant Mycobacterium Avium Subsp. Avium from a Wild Eurasian Otter (Lutra Lutra)

A Review of Non-Invasive Sampling in Wildlife Disease and Health Research: What's New?

Brucellosis in wildlife in Africa: a systematic review and meta-analysis