Comparison of Various Methods in the Sling Adjustment in Stress Urinary Incontinence Surgery
FAN Bozhen,LI Huai fang,XIA Hong,ZHAO Yongfeng,TONG Xiaowen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-1420.2007.12.007
2007-01-01
Journal of Clinical Urology
Abstract:Objective:To analyze retrospectively the effect and complications of different methods in the sling adjustment in the treatment of stress urinary incontinence(SUI).Methods:From August 2003 to December 2005,399 patients with SUI were treated in Tongji hospital of Tongji University.Among them,4 underwent tension free vaginal tape(TVT),126 underwent intravaginal slingplasty(IVS),150 underwent Tong's Hammock anterior,58 underwent tension-free vaginal tape-obturator(TVT-O)and 61 underwent modified TVT-O.Valsalva test,scissors test,stick test and Alice test were used respectively to adjust the stress of the sling,and the postoperative effect and complications of different tests were analyzed.Results:Valsalva test were used in 128 patients,2 were ineffective(loose),124 were satisfied and 2 showed urine retention(tight);Scissors test were used in 98 patients,2 were ineffective,93 were satisfied and 3 showed urine retention;Stick test were used in 96 patients,4 were ineffective,87 were satisfied and 5 showed urine retention;Alice test were used in 77 patients,5 were ineffective,66 were satisfied and 6 showed urine retention.The overall incidence rate of loose cases was 3.3%(13/399)and tight cases was 4.0%(16/399).In the four tests,Valsalva test had least complications while Alice test had most complications.However,no statistical significance was found among these four tests(P0.05).Conclusions:Intravaginal urethra slingplasty was an effective surgery to treat stress urinary incontinence.There were multiple procedures in clinic treatment and the key point lied in the adjustment of the sling,and the difficulty to adjust appropriately the sling stress had limited its extensive use.Valsalva test,scissors test,stick test and Alice test were effective methods to adjust the sling stress based on clinical experience.Compared with other tests,Valsalva test was more complicated,but it was easier to grasp and enjoyed reliable effect and low complications.It could be the springboard to other methods for freshman so as to improve surgery efficiency.