Abstract:Second-order-derivative plus fourth-order-derivative gravity is the ultraviolet completion of second-order-derivative quantum Einstein gravity. While it achieves renormalizability through states of negative Dirac norm, the unitarity violation that this would entail can be postponed to Planck energies. As we show in this paper the theory has a different problem, one that occurs at all energy scales, namely that the Dirac norm of the vacuum of the theory is not finite. To establish this we present a procedure for determining the norm of the vacuum in any quantum field theory. With the Dirac norm of the vacuum of the second-order-derivative plus fourth-order-derivative theory not being finite, the Feynman rules that are used to establish renormalizability are not valid, as is the assumption that the theory can be used as an effective theory at energies well below the Planck scale. This lack of finiteness is also manifested in the fact that the Minkowski path integral for the theory is divergent. Because the vacuum Dirac norm is not finite, the Hamiltonian of the theory is not Hermitian. However, it turns out to be $PT$ symmetric. And when one continues the theory into the complex plane and uses the $PT$ symmetry inner product, viz. the overlap of the left-eigenstate of the Hamiltonian with its right-eigenstate, one then finds that for the vacuum this norm is both finite and positive, the Feynman rules now are valid, the Minkowski path integral now is well behaved, and the theory now can serve as a low energy effective theory. Consequently, the theory can now be offered as a fully consistent, unitary and renormalizable theory of quantum gravity.

Six-Derivative Gravitation and UV-Finiteness

Normalization of the vacuum and the ultraviolet completion of Einstein gravity

Ultraviolet finite resummation of perturbative quantum gravity

Fixed Points of Quantum Gravity and the Dimensionality of the UV Critical Surface

Robustness of the derivative expansion in Asymptotic Safety

Progress on Ultraviolet Finiteness of Supergravity

Deformations of Extremal Black Holes and the UV

Quantum Gravity: A Fluctuating Point of View

On the running and the UV limit of Wilsonian renormalization group flows

On the ultraviolet behavior of conformally reduced quadratic gravity

The Asymptotic Safety Scenario in Quantum Gravity -- An Introduction

A New Non-Renormalization Theorem from UV/IR Mixing

Pauli-Villars and the ultraviolet completion of Einstein gravity

UV finiteness of 3D Yang-Mills theories with a regulating mass in the Landau gauge

Ultraviolet-complete quantum field theories with fractional operators

Critical Reflections on Asymptotically Safe Gravity

UV-complete 4-derivative scalar field theory

Asymptotic safety in Lorentzian quantum gravity