The Integration of Urban Freight in Public Transportation: A Systematic Literature Review

Amine Mohamed El Amrani,Mouhsene Fri,Othmane Benmoussa,Naoufal Rouky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16135286

IF: 3.9

2024-06-22

Sustainability

Abstract:Urban logistics face growing complexity as cities seek sustainable development pathways; one solution is integrating freight transportation with public transit. The purpose of this study is to evaluate current practices, identify gaps, and highlight opportunities for advancement in this field. Through a comprehensive literature review guided by four research questions, this study evaluates methodologies, vehicle choices, the application of intermodal containers, and the shared use of public transportation infrastructure for freight delivery. A meticulous search methodology was employed to select references, which were then analyzed and classified into two main tables. Findings reveal a progression from initial pilot projects and cost analyses to sophisticated planning and optimization challenges, with a focus on metro networks and buses. This study uncovers a predilection for certain research types, the utilization of varied transportation modes, underexplored intermodal container use, and an emerging emphasis on transshipment operations. The integration of freight and public transportation within urban settings is identified as a dynamic and diversifying field, with significant potential for contributing to sustainable urban development. We outline nine areas for future research, including the incorporation of external costs and congestion effects into optimization models, and the exploration of unmanned vehicles, thereby laying the groundwork for more inclusive and efficient urban logistics solutions.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the integration of urban freight and public transportation, aiming to assess current practices, identify research gaps, and highlight opportunities for future development. Specifically, the paper uses a systematic literature review to analyze how urban freight can utilize existing public transportation resources (such as bus and subway networks) for goods transportation to address the last-mile delivery problem in urban logistics.

The core issues addressed in the paper include:
1. **Methodology**: Evaluating different research methods in the field of urban freight and public transportation integration;
2. **Choice of Transportation Modes**: Discussing the types of transportation modes used for urban freight, including the application of intermodal containers;
3. **Infrastructure Sharing**: Analyzing how urban freight can utilize public transportation infrastructure for delivery;
4. **Intermodal Transport and Last-Mile Delivery**: Focusing on how to optimize public transportation networks to improve urban freight efficiency, particularly in last-mile delivery.

Through a comprehensive analysis of relevant literature, the paper reveals trends from initial pilot projects and cost analyses to complex planning and optimization challenges, with a focus on the application of subway networks and buses. Additionally, the paper points out preferences for certain types of research, the utilization of multiple transportation modes, the underuse of intermodal containers, and emerging focuses on transshipment operations. Finally, the authors propose nine future research directions, including incorporating external costs and congestion effects into optimization models and exploring the application of autonomous vehicles, laying the foundation for more inclusive and efficient urban logistics solutions.