The development and realisation of a multi-faceted system for green building planning: A case in Ningbo using the fuzzy analytical hierarchy process

Zhilei Li,D.H.C Chow,De Ding,Jia Ying,Yingjian Hu,Hong Chen,Wei Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2020.110371

IF: 7.201

2020-11-01

Energy and Buildings

Abstract:<p>After the Green Building Regulations in the Zhejiang Province was put into effect in May 2016, cities and prefectures in the province were given directives to set their own individual targets for the provision of green buildings. The city of Ningbo decided to use this opportunity to develop a systematic procedure, using Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (FAHP), to identify which allotments within the municipal area have the greatest potential of delivering green buildings, ensuring the set targets are fair and deliverable.</p><p>This paper explains in detail the use of FAHP in the production of the Specific Plans for Green Buildings for the city of Ningbo in the Zhejiang Province of China. This innovative multi-faceted method incorporates the level of development in each of the 3213 land allotments in the municipal area, assessing each one for critical aspects such as environmental potential, local economic development land-use and land prices in order to determine an individual roadmap for the ratio of green buildings to be built in each region within the city. This method incorporates a scientific process, in which Pairwise Comparison Analysis was conducted for the selected criteria and aspects to determine the weighting factors and scores in each case. This allowed planners to rank all allotments in the municipal area in terms of their potential to provide green buildings, and thus make the setting of targets to provide these accordingly. This approach breaks away from the traditional method which relies on simple estimation, which is often unjustified. Over the two years since this method was introduced, the effects had been positive, within all the allotments abiding to the set targets. Other cities and regions in China, such as the provinces of Liaoning and Hebei, have also adopted this process.</p><p>The Specific Plans for Green Buildings in Ningbo also include the adoption rate of prefabricated buildings and the mandatory date for when by which new residential buildings should be fully-furnished before they are sold (this is not currently the case in most residential buildings in China). These aspects are also discussed in this paper.</p>

energy & fuels,construction & building technology,engineering, civil

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the methods and practices of establishing a multi-faceted system for green building planning in Ningbo City, Zhejiang Province, China. Specifically, the paper addresses the following key issues:

1. **Goal Setting**: Following the implementation of green building regulations in Zhejiang Province in 2016, cities and regions were required to set their own green building goals. Ningbo City decided to use the Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (FAHP) to identify which plots within the city had the highest potential for green building construction, ensuring that the set goals were both fair and achievable.

2. **Innovative Approach**: The paper provides a detailed introduction to the application of FAHP in the specific green building planning of Ningbo City. This method took into account the development level of 3,213 land plots in the city, evaluating factors such as environmental potential, local economic development, land use, and land price to determine a personalized roadmap for the green building ratio in each area.

3. **Scientific Process**: Pairwise Comparison Analysis was used to evaluate the selected criteria and aspects to determine the weight factors and scores in each case. This allowed planners to rank all plots based on their potential to provide green buildings, thereby setting reasonable goals.

4. **Breaking Traditional Methods**: This approach broke away from the traditional methods that relied on simple estimates, which often lacked a basis. Since the introduction of this method in 2018, the results have been positive, with all plots adhering to the set goals. Other cities and regions in China, such as parts of Liaoning Province and Hebei Province, have also adopted this process.

5. **Green Building Standards**: The paper also discusses China's "Three-Star System" for green building evaluation standards, as well as specific plans in Zhejiang Province regarding the mandatory dates for the adoption rate of prefabricated buildings and the sale of fully decorated new residences.

6. **Achieving Goals**: The paper describes how to use scientific procedures and FAHP to set goals, which helps make the goals more realistic and achievable, avoiding the unscientific goal-setting methods of the past.

7. **Overall Goals and Allocation**: Before setting the overall city-wide goals, the paper studied the current situation of other cities in China with similar climates and economic development, and the expert panel discussed the goals that Ningbo could realistically achieve. The paper also mentioned additional goals, such as the proportion of prefabricated buildings, the proportion of residential buildings sold before full decoration, and the proportion of rainwater runoff as part of the requirements for a sponge city.

8. **Technical Roadmap**: To effectively implement the overall goals, it was necessary to understand the potential for sustainability of each plot in depth. The paper used FAHP to assess the capability of each plot to develop green buildings, based on objective technical factors such as the economic land use efficiency and green area ratio, as well as social impact factors like investment entities and land use.

In summary, the paper addressed the issue of scientifically setting and achieving green building goals in urban planning, providing an innovative method based on FAHP to promote low-carbon and sustainable development in Chinese cities.