Abstract:In this meta-analysis, we synthesize the results of 24 studies using the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey (CLASS) and the Maryland Physics Expectations Survey (MPEX) to answer several questions: (1) How does physics instruction impact students' beliefs? (2) When do physics majors develop expert-like beliefs? and (3) How do students' beliefs impact their learning of physics? We report that in typical physics classes, students' beliefs deteriorate or at best stay the same. There are a few types of interventions, including an explicit focus on model-building and/or developing expert- like beliefs that lead to significant improvements in beliefs. Further, small courses and those for elementary education and non-science majors also result in improved beliefs. However, because the available data oversamples certain types of classes, it is unclear whether these improvements are actually due to the interventions, or due to the small class size, or student population typical of the kinds of classes in which these interventions are most often used. Physics majors tend to enter their undergraduate education with more expert-like beliefs than non-majors and these beliefs remain relatively stable throughout their undergraduate careers. Thus, typical physics courses appear to be selecting students who already have strong beliefs, rather than supporting students in developing strong beliefs. There is a small correlation between students' incoming beliefs about physics and their gains on conceptual mechanics surveys. This suggests that students with more expert-like incoming beliefs may learn more in their physics courses, but this finding should be further explored and replicated. Some unanswered questions remain. To answer these questions, we advocate several specific types of future studies.

Lessons From the Physics-Education Reform Effort

Analyzing Reform and Practice of College Physics Experiment Course Teaching

A brief history of physics education in the United States

Introduction to physics teaching for science and engineering undergraduates

Physics Pedagogy and Assessment in Secondary Schools in the U.S.

Reinventing college physics for biologists: Explicating an epistemological curriculum

Students' views about the nature of experimental physics

Physics Education in EU High Schools: Knowledge, Curriculum, and Student Understanding

Development of a global landscape of undergraduate physics laboratory courses

K-12 Teaching and Physics Enrollment

An epistemology and expectations survey about experimental physics: Development and initial results

How physics instruction impacts students' beliefs about learning physics: A meta-analysis of 24 studies

An introduction to physics education research

From F=ma to Flying Squirrels: Curricular Change in an Introductory Physics Course

Physics instructors knowledge and use of active learning has increased over the last decade but most still lecture too much

Improvement or selection? A longitudinal analysis of students' views about experimental physics in their lab courses

Development and results from a survey on students views of experiments in lab classes and research

Students taught by a first-time instructor using active learning teaching strategies outperform students taught by a highly-regarded traditional instructor

What Can Learn from PER: Physics Education Research?

Sustaining educational reforms in introductory physics

Evaluation of 14 to 15 Year Old Students' Understanding and Attitude towards Learning Einsteinian Physics