Sand fly synthetic sex-aggregation pheromone co-located with insecticide reduces the incidence of infection in the canine reservoir of visceral leishmaniasis: A stratified cluster randomised trial
Orin Courtenay,Erin Dilger,Leo A. Calvo-Bado,Lidija Kravar-Garde,Vicky Carter,Melissa J. Bell,Graziella B. Alves,Raquel Goncalves,Muhammad M. Makhdoomi,Mikel A. González,Caris M. Nunes,Daniel P. Bray,Reginaldo P. Brazil,James G. C. Hamilton,Orin Courtenay,Erin Dilger,Leo A. Calvo-Bado,Lidija Kravar-Garde,Vicky Carter,Melissa J. Bell,Graziella B. Alves,Raquel Goncalves,Muhammad M. Makhdoomi,Mikel A. González,Caris M. Nunes,Daniel P. Bray,Reginaldo P. Brazil,James G. C. Hamilton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0007767
2019-10-25
PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases
Abstract:To evaluate the efficacy of a synthetic sex-aggregation pheromone of the sand fly vector <em>Lu</em>. <em>longipalpis</em>, co-located with residual insecticide, to reduce the infection incidence of <em>Leishmania infantum</em> in the canine reservoir.A stratified cluster randomised trial was designed to detect a 50% reduction in canine incident infection after 24 months in 42 recruited clusters, randomly assigned to one of three intervention arms (14 cluster each): synthetic pheromone + insecticide, insecticide-impregnated dog collars, or placebo control. Infection incidence was measured by seroconversion to anti-<em>Leishmania</em> serum antibody, <em>Leishmania</em> parasite detection and canine tissue parasite loads. Changes in relative <em>Lu</em>. <em>longipalpis</em> abundance within households were measured by setting three CDC light traps per household.A total 1,454 seronegative dogs were followed-up for a median 15.2 (95% C.I.s: 14.6, 16.2) months per cluster. The pheromone + insecticide intervention provided 13% (95% C.I. 0%, 44.0%) protection against anti-<em>Leishmania</em> antibody seroconversion, 52% (95% C.I. 6.2%, 74·9%) against parasite infection, reduced tissue parasite loads by 53% (95% C.I. 5.4%, 76.7%), and reduced household female sand fly abundance by 49% (95% C.I. 8.2%, 71.3%). Variation in the efficacy against seroconversion varied between trial strata. Equivalent protection attributed to the impregnated-collars were 36% (95% C.I. 14.4%, 51.8%), 23% (95% C.I. 0%, 57·5%), 48% (95% C.I. 0%, 73.4%) and 43% (95% C.I. 0%, 67.9%), respectively. Comparison of the two interventions showed no statistically consistent differences in their efficacies; however, the errors were broad for all outcomes. Reductions in sand fly numbers were predominant where insecticide was located (chicken and dog sleeping sites), with no evidence of insecticide-induced repellence onto humans or dogs.The synthetic pheromone co-located with insecticide provides protection particularly against canine <em>L</em>. <em>infantum</em> parasite transmission and sand fly vector abundance. The effect estimates are not dissimilar to those of the insecticide-impregnated collars, which are documented to reduce canine infection incidence, human infection and clinical VL disease incidence, in different global regions. The trialled novel lure-and-kill approach is a low-cost potential vector control tool against ZVL in the Americas.The predominant sand fly vector of the intracellular parasite <em>Leishmania infantum</em>, that causes human and canine visceral leishmaniasis in the Americas, is <em>Lutzomyia longipalpis</em>. Dogs are the proven reservoir. Vector control tools to reduce transmission suited to this predominantly exophilic vector are lacking. Insecticide-impregnated dog collars protect dogs against infectious bites from sand fly vectors, and result in reductions of new infections in both dogs and humans. However, collars are costly for endemic communities, and alternative approaches are needed. Recently the bulk synthesised sex-aggregation pheromone of male <em>Lu</em>. <em>longipalpis</em> was shown to attract large numbers of conspecific females to lethal pyrethroid insecticides, indicating the potential for use in a vector control application. This study, conducted in Brazil, evaluated the efficacy of this novel lure-and-kill approach to reduce seroconversion and infection incidence with <em>L</em>. <em>infantum</em> in the canine reservoir, in addition to measuring its impact on household abundance of <em>Lu</em>. <em>longipalpis</em>. Deployed in 14 stratified clusters, the outcomes were compared to those attributed to insecticide impregnated collars fitted to dogs in another 14 clusters; each intervention was compared to 14 clusters that received placebo treatments. The beneficial effects of the lure-and-kill method were most noticeable on confirmed infection incidence and clinical parasite loads, and in reducing sand fly abundance. The overall effect of the two interventions were not statistically dissimilar, though the confidence intervals were broad. We conclude that the novel low-cost lure-and-kill approach should be added to the vector control toolbox against visceral leishmaniasis in the Americas.
tropical medicine,parasitology