Constraining the chameleon-photon coupling with atomic spectroscopy

Benjamin Elder,Jeremy Sakstein
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.109.124007
IF: 5.407
2024-06-05
Physical Review D
Abstract:We compute bounds from atomic spectroscopy on chameleon fields that couple to the photon. Chameleons are a wide class of scalar field models that generically lead to screened fifth forces and a host of novel phenomenologies, particularly when the photon coupling is included. We account for perturbations to the atomic energy levels from both the scalar field 'fifth force' and the scalar field's correction to the electric field. We also account for the electromagnetic interaction's contribution to the scalar charge of the proton, which enables a considerably wider class of models to be tested than without this effect. We find bounds that cover different areas of chameleon parameter space. A range of models spanning approximately one order of magnitude in chameleon coupling parameters (around M,Mγ≈10−16MPl ) are excluded for the first time. We also show that improvements to the theoretical uncertainty of hydrogen's spectrum within the Standard Model would immediately rule out additional chameleon theory space by this analysis. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.109.124007 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Funded by SCOAP 3 . Published by the American Physical Society
astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems Addressed by the Paper This paper attempts to constrain chameleon fields coupled with photons through atomic spectroscopy, specifically the 1s-2s transition energy of hydrogen atoms. Chameleon fields are a class of scalar field models that typically lead to screened fifth forces and a range of new physical phenomena, especially when photon coupling is involved. ### Specific Issues 1. **Constraints on Chameleon Fields Coupled with Photons**: - The authors constrain the coupling strength of chameleon fields with photons by calculating the perturbation of atomic energy levels due to the chameleon field, particularly considering the "fifth force" effect of the scalar field and the modification of the electric field by the scalar field. - They also consider the impact of electromagnetic interactions on the scalar charge, allowing for the testing of a broader range of models. 2. **Experimental Constraints**: - The authors identify new regions of parameter space that are excluded, with coupling parameters approximately in the range of \( M; M_\gamma \approx 10^{-16} M_{\text{Pl}} \). - They also point out that if the theoretical uncertainty in the hydrogen atom spectrum within the Standard Model is improved, more chameleon theory space will be excluded. ### Methods - **Theoretical Calculations**: - The authors first derive the electrodynamics equations for the scalar field and photons and solve for the distribution of the scalar field around the proton. - They calculate the perturbation of hydrogen atom energy levels due to the scalar field, including direct matter coupling and potential perturbation caused by photon coupling. - **Experimental Data**: - The authors use high-precision measurement data of the hydrogen atom 1s-2s transition energy (with a relative precision of \( 4.2 \times 10^{-15} \)) to constrain the parameter space of the chameleon field. - They compare the theoretical calculation results with experimental data to determine which parameter regions are excluded. ### Conclusions - **New Constraints**: - The authors identify new regions of parameter space that are excluded, with coupling parameters approximately in the range of \( M; M_\gamma \approx 10^{-16} M_{\text{Pl}} \). - These results complement existing experimental constraints, especially in certain specific parameter regions. - **Future Prospects**: - If the theoretical uncertainty in the hydrogen atom spectrum within the Standard Model is further improved, it will enhance the ability to constrain the parameter space of chameleon fields. ### Summary This paper conducts detailed theoretical calculations and experimental constraints on chameleon fields coupled with photons through atomic spectroscopy, specifically the 1s-2s transition energy of hydrogen atoms. The authors identify new regions of parameter space that are excluded and point out directions for future research.