Abstract:This paper analyses the European Union's (EU's) democratising agenda within the frame of the EU's Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade (FLEGT) Voluntary Partnership Agreement (VPA) in Laos. In particular, it focuses on the requirement for the participation of civil society organisations (CSOs) in the VPA and the Lao state actors' responses to this requirement. I frame the VPA's democratising agenda and its conditionality of civil society participation as acts of governmentality exercised by the EU in Laos. This EU governmentality is exercised through the EU and EU member states' funded development partner in the frame of their project supporting the FLEGT VPA process in Laos. The Lao government responses and strategies to the EU governmentality resulted on the one hand in the Lao state's governmentality towards domestic CSOs, and in counter-conduct (i.e. a subtle and sly resistance to some aspects of the VPA) on the other. First, by tracing the establishment of the Lao FLEGT Civil Society Organisations Network (FLEGT CSO Network), I highlight the trend of depoliticisation and rendering technical, where the EU-funded development partner, with full support and backing from the Lao state, trained the CSOs in various VPA and timber legality issues. In the training, the CSOs were given specific roles and tasks, building up their fields of expertise, and were integrated in the formal VPA organisational structures, which allowed for their scrutiny and tight survelience by the state. Second, I analyse the counter-conduct by the Lao government against a civil society that is independent from the state, which the government manifested through further disempowerment of CSOs and tightening of the CSO regulation shortly after the FLEGT CSO Network was established, while at the same time simulating democratisation by welcoming CSOs' participation in the VPA. Summoning CSOs as compliant actors and unpaid service providers working for and alongside the state was in part enabled by the VPA's own rendering technical approach. Hence, the EU's VPA governmentality and the Lao state counter-conduct mutually reinforced one another, even if their initial agendas around democratisation and CSO engagement in forest governance and the VPA diverged.

Indonesian Efforts and Delays in Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade (FLEGT )License Implementation within the European Union

Renting legality: How FLEGT is reinforcing power relations in Indonesian furniture production networks

Effects of EU illegal logging policy on timber-supplying countries: A systematic review

Unraveling disputes between Indonesia and the European Union on Indonesian palm oil: from environmental issues to national dignity

Indonesian Economic Diplomacy toward Palm Oil: Indonesia’s Respond to the EU Resolution on Palm Oil and Deforestation of Rainforest (2016/2222(INI))

Defining the objectives and roles of Indonesian production forest governance through the multi-business forestry policy narrative

The Impact of the European Union’s Palm Oil Resolution Policy on the Indonesian Economy Sector

Only a Noise? The Role of Non-governmental Organizations in the Policy Processes of a New Social Forestry Model in Indonesia

Legal Protection For Indonesian Fishery Products In Facing Environmental Protection In International Trade

Comparative Analysis of Government Communication Strategies in Environmental Law Enforcement: A Case Study of Indonesia (DKI Jakarta) and Singapore

Impact of the European Union Regulations on Indonesian Oil Palm Smallholder Farmers

The impact of the European Union (EU) renewable energy directive policy on the management of Indonesian palm oil industry

Carbon trading system as a climate mitigation scheme: why Indonesia should adopt it?

Questioning Sustainable Environmental Policies and Practices in Indonesia: Would Durkheim’s Structural Functionalism Theory Have a Relevance?

Democracy through technocracy? Reinventing civil society as a state-monitored and unpaid service provider in the EU FLEGT VPA in Laos

Forest law compliance and enforcement: the case of on-farm timber extraction in Ghana

Reviewing Social Forestry in Indonesia through an Integrative Framework for Collaborative Governance

Towards a Fairer Future: Examining Environmental Permits in Indonesia and Sweden Through the Lens of Sustainable Development and Equity

Assessing the impact of limiting Indonesian palm oil exports to the European Union

Policy in Community-Based Environmental Conservation and Protection: A Comparative Study Between Brazil and Indonesia

Comparative Study of State Jurisdiction: The Protection Towards Geographical Indication at Indonesia, the EU and US