Physical Fitness Surveillance and Monitoring Systems Inventory for Children and Adolescents: A Scoping Review with a Global Perspective

Javier Brazo-Sayavera,Danilo R. Silva,Justin J. Lang,Grant R. Tomkinson,Cesar Agostinis-Sobrinho,Lars Bo Andersen,Antonio García-Hermoso,Anelise R. Gaya,Gregor Jurak,Eun-Young Lee,Yang Liu,David R. Lubans,Anthony D. Okely,Francisco B. Ortega,Jonatan R. Ruiz,Mark S. Tremblay,Leandro Dos Santos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-024-02038-9

IF: 11.928

2024-05-08

Sports Medicine

Abstract:Surveillance of health-related physical fitness can improve decision-making and intervention strategies promoting health for children and adolescents. However, no study has comprehensively analyzed surveillance/monitoring systems for physical fitness globally. This review sought to address this gap by identifying: (1) national-level surveillance/monitoring systems for physical fitness among children and adolescents globally, (2) the main barriers and challenges to implementing surveillance/monitoring systems, and (3) governmental actions related to existing surveillance/monitoring systems. We used a scoping review to search, obtain, group, summarize, and analyze available evidence. Our review involved three stages: (1) identification of surveillance systems through a systematic literature review, with complementary search of the grey literature (e.g., reference lists, Google Scholar, webpages, recommendations), (2) systematic consultation with relevant experts using a Delphi method to confirm/add systems and to gather and analyze information on the barriers and challenges to implementing systems, and (3) Web searches for public documents on government sites and surveillance/monitoring system pages, and direct internet searches to identify relevant governmental actions related to surveillance systems. A total of 15 fitness surveillance/monitoring systems met our inclusion criteria. Experts identified a lack of government support and funding, and the low priority of fitness on the public health agenda as the main barriers/challenges to implementation. Several governmental actions related to surveillance systems were identified, including policies, strategies, programs, and guidelines. We propose a Global Observatory of Physical Fitness to help address these issues.

sport sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper primarily explores the current status, challenges, and related government actions of global physical fitness monitoring systems for children and adolescents.

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Address

1. **Identify national-level physical fitness monitoring systems worldwide**: The study aims to identify existing physical fitness monitoring/surveillance systems for children and adolescents in various countries and analyze the characteristics of these systems.

2. **Determine the barriers and challenges in implementing monitoring systems**: The paper also focuses on the main barriers and challenges encountered in the establishment and implementation of such systems.

3. **Evaluate the impact of monitoring systems on public health policy**: Additionally, the authors examine whether these monitoring systems are used to guide public health systems and policy-making.

### Main Findings

- **Global distribution of monitoring systems**: A total of 15 countries worldwide have implemented physical fitness monitoring systems, primarily distributed in Europe (7), Asia (4), North America (2), and South America (2). Australia and Africa currently do not have national-level monitoring systems.

- **Major challenges**: The lack of government support and insufficient funding are the most significant challenges, followed by the low priority of physical fitness in the public health agenda.

- **Government actions**: Most of the identified monitoring systems are associated with government actions, such as the formulation of "Physical Activity Guidelines," "National Strategies for Promoting Physical Activity," and internal departmental reports on the status of physical fitness.

Through this study, the authors hope to raise awareness of the importance of physical fitness monitoring for children and adolescents and to encourage more countries and regions to take effective measures to establish or improve corresponding monitoring systems.