Mark Zajac Gerald L. Jones,James A. Glazier
Abstract:In this paper we argue that the pattern of cell movements in the morphogenetic process known as convergent extension can be understood as a energy minimization process, provided the cell-cell adhesive energy has a certain kind of anisotropy. This single simple property is sufficient cause for the type of cell elongation, alignment, and intercalation of a cellular array that is the characteristic of convergent extension. We describe the type of anisotropy required. We show that the final aspect ratio of the array of cells is independent of the initial configuration and of the degree of cell elongation. We find how it depends on the anisotropy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to explain a specific cell rearrangement phenomenon in animal morphogenesis, namely "convergent extension", through the energy minimization process. Specifically, the author explored how cells achieve elongation, alignment and interpenetration through the anisotropic adhesion energy between cells during morphogenesis, which results in the tissue stretching in a certain direction.
### Detailed description of the main problem:
1. **Background and phenomenon**:
- During animal embryonic development, especially during gastrulation, cells will undergo large - scale rearrangement. One common rearrangement method is "convergent extension", that is, the cell population will become longer in one direction and narrower in the perpendicular direction.
- This phenomenon is particularly evident in the development of the precursor structure of the vertebrate spine. The cells are initially isodiametric, and then gradually elongate and line up, and at the same time, interpenetration occurs in the alignment direction, and finally the cell population stretches in the orthogonal direction of the alignment direction.
2. **Existing theories and deficiencies**:
- Previous studies have mainly focused on experimental observations and descriptive models, lacking a unified energy minimization framework to explain this phenomenon.
- In particular, in the experiments of Shih and Keller, a layer of cells isolated from frog embryos still showed strong convergent extension on a uniform surface, indicating that there is some collective mechanism within the cells driving this process.
3. **Research objectives**:
- Propose a theoretical model based on energy minimization to explain how cells achieve elongation, alignment and interpenetration through anisotropic inter - cellular adhesion energy during the convergent extension process.
- Determine the required anisotropic conditions and prove that these conditions are sufficient to cause the convergent extension phenomenon.
- Verify whether the aspect ratio of the final cell population is independent of the initial configuration and explore its specific relationship depending on anisotropy.
### Core hypotheses of the paper:
- **Anisotropic adhesion energy**: It is assumed that the adhesion energy between cells depends on the direction of the contact surface relative to the cell elongation axis. For example, the contact surface parallel to the elongation axis (long - long contacts) has a lower energy density, while the contact surface perpendicular to the elongation axis (short - short contacts) has a higher energy density.
- **Energy minimization**: It is assumed that the cell system tends to reach a stable state through energy minimization, which means that cells will spontaneously elongate, align and interpenetrate in the alignment direction to reduce the total adhesion energy.
### Mathematical expression:
Let \( J_{ll} \), \( J_{ss} \) and \( J_{ls} \) represent the energy densities of long - long, short - short and long - short contact surfaces respectively, then the total energy \( E \) can be expressed as:
\[ E = L_{ll}J_{ll}+L_{ss}J_{ss}+L_{ls}J_{ls} \]
Among them, \( L_{ll} \), \( L_{ss} \) and \( L_{ls} \) are the total lengths of different types of contact surfaces respectively. In order to make the energy of the ordered arrangement lower than that of the disordered arrangement, the following conditions need to be met:
\[ \gamma_{ls}=J_{ls}-\frac{J_{ll} + J_{ss}}{2}>0 \]
In addition, assuming \( J_{ll}<J_{ss}<0 \), it can further promote cell elongation and alignment.
Through these assumptions and mathematical derivations, the author shows how to explain the convergent extension phenomenon with the principle of energy minimization and proposes a reasonable theoretical framework to understand this complex biological process.