On Coherency-Induced Ordering in Substitutional Alloys: I. Analytical

Dean J. Lee,Jong K. Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/9911267

1999-11-24

Abstract:As pointed out by Linus Pauling in his classic work on the relationship between crystal packing and ionic radius ratio, a difference in atomic size can be accommodated more readily by an ordered structure than by a disordered one. Because of mathematical complexity, however, very few works have been reported for substitutional alloys. In this work, coherency-induced ordering in substitutional alloys is examined through a simple model based on a two-dimensional square lattice. Within the assumption of nearest neighbor interactions on a square lattice, both modified Bragg-Williams and Onsager approaches show that coherency strain arising due to atomic mismatch can exert profound effects on order-disorder transitions in substitutional alloys. If the alloy system is elastically homogeneous and Vegard's law is obeyed, the order-disorder transition is of a second-order kinetics. If the atomic mismatches significantly deviate from Vegard's law, however, the transition may become a first-order kinetics, as the configurational free energy surface is composed of double wells. At the transition of a first-order kinetics, the lattice parameter can either increase or decrease upon heating, i.e., the lattice parameter of an ordered state can be less or greater than that of a disordered state. The results of Onsager's approach are independently confirmed with those of the Discrete Atom Method, a Monte Carlo technique predicated upon the combination of statistical mechanics and linear elasticity.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore the influence of coherent strain caused by atomic mismatch on the order - disorder transition in substitutional alloys. Specifically, through a simplified model based on a two - dimensional square lattice, the author studied how elastic strain affects the ordering process in substitutional alloys under the assumption of nearest - neighbor interactions.

#### Main problems:
1. **Influence of elastic strain on the order - disorder transition**: The article attempts to understand why elastic strain resulting from atomic size differences significantly affects the phase - change behavior of alloys from an ordered to a disordered state.
2. **Transition between the second - and first - order phase transitions**: If the alloy system is elastically homogeneous and follows Vegard's law, the order - disorder transition exhibits second - order kinetics; however, if the atomic mismatch significantly deviates from Vegard's law, the transition may become first - order kinetics, which will lead to a double - well structure in the free - energy surface.
3. **Lattice parameter changes**: During the first - order kinetic transition, the lattice parameter may increase or decrease upon heating, that is, the lattice parameter in the ordered state can be smaller or larger than that in the disordered state.

### Research methods
The author used two main methods to study these problems:
1. **Improved Bragg - Williams method**: By considering the bond - enthalpy and strain energy, the configurational free energy of equiatomic substitutional AB alloys was analyzed, and an expression for the lattice parameter δ was derived.
2. **Onsager model**: Based on a two - dimensional square lattice, considering the chemical interaction energy and strain energy, the results of the Bragg - Williams method were further verified.
3. **Discrete Atom Method (DAM)**: A Monte Carlo technique that combines statistical mechanics and linear elastic theory independently verified the results of the Onsager model.

### Conclusions
The study found that in the case of elastic homogeneity and following Vegard's law, the order - disorder transition exhibits second - order kinetics; when the atomic mismatch significantly deviates from Vegard's law, the transition may become first - order kinetics. In addition, the change in the lattice parameter depends on how ε3 deviates from 0.5ε2. These results provide important physical insights into understanding the influence of elastic strain on the ordering of substitutional alloys.

### Formula summary
- Expression for the lattice parameter δ:
\[
\delta=\frac{\varepsilon_2^2+\varepsilon_3 - 2\varepsilon_3\varepsilon_2}{4}
\]
- Relationship between the reduced free energy g and the temperature θ:
\[
g = \frac{R^2}{16}\left(\frac{16\Omega_c}{k\varepsilon_2^2}\right)-\frac{R^4}{2}\left(\frac{2\varepsilon_3}{\varepsilon_2}-1\right)^2-2\theta\left[(1 + R)\ln(1 + R)-(1 - R)\ln(1 - R)\right]
\]

These formulas indicate that when the system follows Vegard's law (i.e., \(2\varepsilon_3=\varepsilon_2\)), the lattice parameter is independent of the long - range order parameter R, thus exhibiting second - order kinetics; otherwise, the system may exhibit a first - order kinetic transition.