Abstract:The cosmic censorship hypothesis introduced by Penrose thirty years ago is still one of the most important open questions in {\it classical} general relativity. The main goal of this paper is to put forward the idea that cosmic censorship is intrinsically a {\it quantum} phenomena. We construct a gedanken experiment which seems to violate the cosmic censorship principle within the purely {\it classical} framework of general relativity. We prove, however, that {\it quantum} physics restores the validity of the conjecture. It is therefore suggested that cosmic censorship might be enforced by a quantum theory of gravity.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Astrophysics,High Energy Physics - Theory,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the validity of the cosmic censorship hypothesis and its relationship with quantum physics. Specifically, the author Shahar Hod explored the following issues:
1. **Stability of the cosmic censorship hypothesis**: This hypothesis was proposed by Penrose 30 years ago. It holds that in the framework of classical general relativity, any spacetime singularity will be hidden by the black - hole event horizon and thus will not be visible to distant observers. Although this hypothesis is regarded as one of the important pillars of classical general relativity, it still lacks a strict mathematical proof so far.
2. **Challenges in the classical framework**: Hod, through constructing a thought experiment (gedanken experiment), showed that in a purely classical framework, some charged objects may be sucked into a black hole and remove its event horizon, thus exposing the singularity, which would violate the cosmic censorship hypothesis.
3. **The role of quantum effects**: In order to verify this hypothesis, Hod further proved that quantum effects can restore the validity of the cosmic censorship hypothesis. Specifically, he pointed out that the vacuum polarization effects and the Schwinger discharge mechanism can limit the strength of the black - hole electric field and prevent charged particles from destroying the black - hole event horizon.
### Main conclusions
- **Powerlessness of classical effects**: In a purely classical framework, when a charged object is sucked into a black hole, it is indeed possible to remove the event horizon and expose the singularity.
- **Crucial role of quantum effects**: After introducing quantum effects, especially the vacuum polarization effect, this phenomenon of singularity exposure can be effectively prevented, thus maintaining the validity of the cosmic censorship hypothesis.
- **Possibility of a quantum gravity theory**: Based on the above analysis, the author speculates that the cosmic censorship hypothesis may need to rely on a quantum gravity theory to be strictly valid.
### Formula summary
The formulas involved in the paper are mainly used to describe the energy contribution of charged objects and the limiting conditions of the black - hole electric field. For example:
- The total energy \(E(\ell)\) of a charged object consists of three parts:
\[
E(\ell)=\frac{\mu \ell(r_{+}-r_{-})}{2r_{+}^{2}}+\frac{qQ}{r_{+}}-\frac{qQ\ell^{2}(r_{+}-r_{-})}{4r_{+}^{4}}+\frac{Mq^{2}}{2r_{+}^{2}}
\]
where \(r_{\pm}=M\pm\sqrt{M^{2}-Q^{2}}\) are the positions of the inner and outer horizons of the black hole.
- Quantum limiting conditions of the black - hole electric field:
\[
E\leq E_{c}=\frac{\pi m_{e}^{2}}{\vert e\vert\hbar}
\]
where \(m_{e}\) and \(e\) are the rest mass and charge of an electron respectively.
These formulas show that when quantum effects are considered, charged objects cannot destroy the black - hole event horizon, thus ensuring the validity of the cosmic censorship hypothesis.