The Effects of Gas Dynamics, Cooling, Star Formation, and Numerical Resolution in Simulations of Cluster Formation

G. F. Lewis,A. Babul,N. Katz,T. Quinn,L. Hernquist,D. H. Weinberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/308954

2000-02-11

Abstract:We present the analysis of a suite of simulations of a Virgo mass galaxy cluster. Undertaken within the framework of standard cold dark matter cosmology, these simulations were performed at differing resolutions and with increasingly complex physical processes, with the goal of identifying the effects of each on the evolution of the cluster. We focus on the cluster at the present epoch and examine properties including the radial distributions of density, temperature, entropy and velocity. We also map `observable' projected properties such as the surface mass density, X-ray surface brightness and SZ signature. We identify significant differences between the simulations, which highlights the need for caution when comparing numerical simulations to observations of galaxy clusters. While resolution affects the inner density profile in dark matter simulations, the addition of a gaseous component, especially one that cools and forms stars, affects the entire cluster. We conclude that both resolution and included physical processes play an important role in simulating the formation and evolution of galaxy clusters. Therefore, physical inferences drawn from simulations that do not include a gaseous component that can cool and form stars present a poor representation of reality. (Abridged)

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: within the framework of standard cold dark matter cosmology, study the influence of different resolutions and physical processes on the simulation results of galaxy cluster formation. Specifically, the author hopes to identify through a series of simulation experiments with different resolutions and different degrees of physical complexity how these factors affect the evolution of galaxy clusters, especially their radial distribution characteristics such as density, temperature, entropy and velocity, as well as the observable properties projected into two - dimensional space, such as surface mass density, X - ray surface brightness and Sunyaev - Zel'dovich effect.

### Main problems

1. **Influence of resolution**:
- What is the impact of different gravitational force resolutions (from 200 kpc to 14 kpc) on the simulation results?
- For example, in the simulation of gas dynamics without cooling, how does increasing the resolution change the X - ray luminosity and emission - weighted temperature?

2. **Influence of physical processes**:
- What is the impact of adding gas components (especially gas that can cool and form stars) on the entire galaxy cluster?
- For example, when cooling and star formation are included in the simulation, 30% of the baryonic matter in the galaxy cluster will be converted into stars and produce a huge central galaxy, which significantly changes the potential well of the galaxy cluster.

3. **Comparison between observation and simulation**:
- What are the differences between the simulation results and the actually observed properties of galaxy clusters?
- In particular, in high - resolution simulations, after adding cooling and star formation, the X - ray luminosity and emission - weighted temperature of the galaxy cluster are increased by 20% and 30% respectively, which are closer to the observed XD galaxy clusters.

### Conclusion

The author concludes that resolution and the included physical processes play a crucial role in simulating the formation and evolution of galaxy clusters. Therefore, simulations that only include dark matter or simply handle baryonic components may not accurately reflect the real situation. In order to better understand the formation and evolution of galaxy clusters, complex physical processes such as gas cooling and star formation must be fully considered in the simulations.

Through this series of simulation experiments, the author emphasizes the need to be cautious about numerical simulation results when studying galaxy clusters, and points out that future simulations should increase the resolution as much as possible and incorporate more physical processes to obtain more accurate results.