S. Goriely,B. Clerbaux
Abstract:Recent observations of r-nuclei, and in particular of Th, in ultra-metal poor stars revived the old idea that the Th cosmochronometry could provide an age estimate of the oldest stars in the Galaxy, and therefore a lower limit to the age of the Galaxy. Unfortunately, some nuclear, astrophysics and observational uncertainties still affect the theoretical r-process models required to predict the original production of Th. The impact of these uncertainties on the prediction of the age of the Galaxy is analyzed and discussed. Although the present study suggests that at the moment great care should be taken in estimating the age of the stars on the basis of the observed Th abundance, new accurate observations of heavy r-elements could put the Th cosmochronometry on safer grounds, especially if Th and U lines could be observed accurately and simultaneously in metal-poor stars.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?
This paper aims to solve the problem of uncertainty when estimating the ages of ancient stars in the Milky Way by the thorium (Th) cosmochronology method. Specifically, the author explores the following aspects:
1. **Theoretical basis of thorium cosmochronology**:
- Thorium is a long - lived radioactive element, and its decay can be used to estimate the age of a star. According to the formula:
\[
\left(\frac{\text{Th}}{\text{Eu}}\right)_{\text{obs}} = \left(\frac{\text{Th}}{\text{Eu}}\right)_{r} \exp\left(-\frac{T^*}{\tau(\text{Th})}\right)
\]
where \(\tau(\text{Th}) = 20.27\) Gyr is the characteristic α - decay time scale of thorium, and \(T^*\) is the age of the star. By comparing the observed thorium abundance with that in the solar system, the age of the star can be estimated.
2. **Uncertainties in the r - process model**:
- The r - process is one of the main nucleosynthesis processes for producing heavy elements, but there are still many uncertainties and challenges in the current understanding of the r - process. These uncertainties mainly come from the following aspects:
- **Nuclear physics inputs**: such as nuclear mass, deformation, (n,γ) and (γ,n) reaction rates, α and β decay half - lives, and fission probabilities, etc.
- **Astrophysical conditions**: such as temperature, neutron density, and the number of neutrons captured by each seed nucleus, etc.
- **Limitations of parameterized models**: Due to the lack of accurate experimental data, many nuclear physical quantities need to be extrapolated based on theory, which introduces additional uncertainties.
3. **Uncertainties in observational data**:
- There is a certain error range in the observed thorium abundance in extremely metal - poor stars (such as CS 22892 - 052). In addition, there are also uncertainties in the europium (Eu) abundance normalization, which will affect the final age estimate.
4. **Potential ways to improve thorium cosmochronology**:
- The author points out that future high - precision observations, especially those of lead (Pb), bismuth (Bi) or uranium (U), may provide a more reliable basis for thorium cosmochronology. The observations of these elements can help better constrain the r - process model and reduce the uncertainties in age estimates.
In summary, through a detailed analysis of various uncertainties involved in thorium cosmochronology, this paper aims to evaluate and improve the reliability of this method in estimating the ages of ancient stars in the Milky Way.