The origin of single radio pulsars

Simon Portegies Zwart,Edward van den Heuvel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S1384-1076%2899%2900029-9

1999-02-12

Abstract:By comparing relative rates of supernovae versus formation rates of single radio pulsars, recycled pulsars, binary pulsars and X-ray binaries we put strong limits on the progenitors of radio pulsars and on the requirement of an asymmetry in the supernova. The assumption that radio pulsars are only formed in type Ib and type Ic supernovae from interacting binaries (Iben & Tutukov 1996) breaks down on the implication that in that case either the formation rate of binary pulsars (double neutron stars) should be of the order of 20%, of the single pulsar birthrate or, alternatively, almost all single pulsars (85% to 98%) should originate from Thorne-Zytkow stars. In the latter case the pulsar velocity distribution is inconsistent with observations. Also, in that case the difference between the supernova rate and the pulsar formation rate would be about one order of magnitude, i.e.: much larger than observed. Allowing type II supernovae from single stars and non-interacting binaries to form radio pulsars solves this conundrum, but then a kick is required in order to explain the high velocities of single radio pulsars. A kick is also required to understand the small birthrate, relative to the supernova rate, of binary pulsars consisting of two neutron stars.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the origin of single radio pulsars. Specifically, by comparing the supernova explosion rate with the formation rates of different types of pulsars (including single radio pulsars, recycled pulsars, binary pulsars, and X - ray binaries), the author explores the progenitor stars of radio pulsars and whether asymmetry (the so - called "kick" mechanism) is required during the supernova explosion process. The main purpose of the paper is to verify the following hypothesis: whether radio pulsars are only produced by Type Ib and Type Ic supernovae (from interacting binary systems), or whether Type II supernovae (from single stars or non - interacting wide binary systems) also contribute to the formation of radio pulsars.

### Summary of Main Problems:

1. **Types of Progenitor Stars of Radio Pulsars**:
- Are radio pulsars only produced by Type Ib and Type Ic supernovae (from interacting binary systems)?
- Are Type II supernovae (from single stars or non - interacting wide binary systems) also involved in the formation of radio pulsars?

2. **Asymmetry during the Supernova Explosion Process**:
- Is asymmetry (the "kick" mechanism) in the supernova explosion required to explain the high spatial velocity of single radio pulsars?
- What is the impact of this asymmetry on the formation of double - neutron - star systems?

### Core Arguments of the Paper:

- **Hypothesis A**: Radio pulsars are only produced by Type Ib and Type Ic supernovae, and these supernovae occur in interacting binary systems. According to this hypothesis, the author finds that either the formation rate of double - neutron - star systems should account for 20% of the birth rate of single pulsars, or almost all single pulsars (85% - 98%) originate from Thorne - Żytkow objects, which is inconsistent with the observational results.

- **Hypothesis B**: Allow Type II supernovae (from single stars or non - interacting wide binary systems) to also produce radio pulsars. In this case, asymmetry (the "kick" mechanism) needs to be introduced to explain the high spatial velocity of single radio pulsars and also to explain the low formation rate of double - neutron - star systems.

### Conclusion:

Through simple analysis and detailed population synthesis calculations, the author concludes that Type II supernovae (from single stars or non - interacting wide binary systems) must be involved in the formation of radio pulsars, and the asymmetry in the supernova explosion (the "kick" mechanism) best explains the observed characteristics of radio pulsars.

### Formula Representation:

- The formation rate of single radio pulsars: \[ \text{Single Pulsar Formation Rate} = \frac{\alpha(1 - x)(1 - y)}{y + x(1 - y)+ 2(1 - \alpha)(1 - x)(1 - y)} \]
where:
- \( y \) is the proportion of binary systems that are disrupted after the first supernova explosion.
- \( x \) is the proportion of high - energy X - ray binaries that completely spiral - merge to form Thorne - Żytkow objects.
- \( \alpha \) is the proportion of binary systems that remain binary after the second supernova explosion.

Through these analyses, the paper solves the key problems regarding the origin of radio pulsars and proposes a model that is more in line with the observational data.