How good a doctor do you need to be?

D. Sokol
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e7858
2012-11-21
British Medical Journal
Abstract:If doctors have a duty of care, they must act with adequate skill. But what does that actually mean?
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the interaction between the supernova remnant (SNR) RCW103 and the interstellar medium (ISM), especially the impact of the fast shock (with a speed of about 1000 km/s) on the ISM. Specifically, the research focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Measurement of metallicity**: Through infrared spectral observations, researchers hope to obtain abundance information of various elements (such as Si, Fe, Ni, etc.) in young supernova remnants. This helps to understand the material composition in these remnants and their evolutionary history. 2. **Destruction efficiency of dust grains**: By comparing the abundances of refractory elements (such as Si, Fe) and non - refractory elements (such as Ne, P, S, Cl, Ar), the destruction efficiency of shock waves on dust grains can be evaluated. This helps to understand how shock waves affect solid particles in the interstellar medium. 3. **Shock model verification**: Researchers hope to verify the existing shock model predictions through observational data. In particular, they focus on whether the emission line intensity and velocity width are in line with the model expectations. For example, some models predict that the pre - shock region should emit strong high - ionization - species emission lines, but the observational results are inconsistent with this. 4. **Abundance anomaly of nickel**: The paper pays special attention to the abundance problem of nickel (Ni). Optical and infrared [NiII] emission lines show that the abundance of nickel is about an order of magnitude higher than the solar abundance, which is difficult to explain with the existing physical mechanisms. Researchers attempt to explain this abnormal phenomenon by analyzing the emission lines of different ions. ### Research background RCW103 is a young supernova remnant, with an age of about 1000 years and a shock speed of about 1200 km/s. It interacts with high - density ISM clouds, causing the gas behind the shock to cool and recombine rapidly, forming a radiative supernova remnant. This special environment makes RCW103 an ideal laboratory for studying the interaction between fast shock waves and the ISM. ### Main findings 1. **Metallicities close to solar values**: Except for nickel, all measured element abundances are close to solar values, indicating that the shock has destroyed all dust grains and returned refractory elements to the gas phase. 2. **Abundance anomaly of nickel**: The [NiII] λ6.64 µm emission line shows that the abundance of nickel is about an order of magnitude higher than the solar value. Researchers believe that this may be due to a systematic underestimation in the calculation of the [NiII] collision cross - section, resulting in an overestimation of the nickel abundance. 3. **Shock model inconsistency**: The observed emission line intensity and velocity width mainly come from the post - shock region, and the contribution of the pre - shock region is very small or almost non - existent. This is inconsistent with the predictions of existing shock models, especially for the emission lines of high - ionization species. ### Conclusion This study, through infrared spectral observations of RCW103, reveals the complexity of the interaction between fast shock waves and the ISM. Although the abundances of most elements are as expected, the anomaly in nickel abundance still requires further study. In addition, the observational results pose a challenge to the existing shock models, suggesting that the models need to be improved to better describe this complex astrophysical process.