Abstract:This article takes a closer look at the arguments and intellectual context of theological and medical discourse on masturbation in the early stages of the anti‐masturbation campaign, from about 1680 to 1730. It identifies a first stage, during which moralist and religious writing dominated the campaign. The authors used medical arguments on the fatal health hazards of masturbation in support of their message. But the crucial shift in religious discourse on masturbation compared to previous times was the emphatic association of masturbation with the sin of Onan. This shift is linked, in particular, to the rise of traducianist accounts of human conception among Protestant theologians of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. While traditional Aristotelian and Thomistic philosophy claimed that the rational human soul was created and infused by God only weeks after conception, traducianists saw the parental semen itself as the decisive vehicle for the transmission of the immortal human soul. Within this framework, the ontological and theological status of semen changed markedly. Traducianism remained far from being universally accepted, but it created a growing readiness to accept that the immortal soul was at least potentialiter in the semen. Masturbation came much closer to murder, or was even explicitly condemned as such. The deadly punishment which God had inflicted on Onan for having spilled his semen was fully justified. During a second stage, from about 1710, medical arguments increasingly took the forefront. A group of London venereal specialists elaborated on occasional earlier claims that masturbation damaged the genital vessels and fibres, bringing forth impotence, seminal efflux and gleets with devastating long‐term effects on the whole body. John Marten, the anonymous author of “Onania” and various members of the venereal trade published extensively on the topic and popularised the issue of masturbation and its health effects on an unprecedented scale. At the same time, they further strengthened the link between masturbation and the sin of Onan. Like Onan (and his brother Er), every “onanian” would bring death upon himself. In parallel development, some academic physicians began to question the validity of traditional fears of “seminal retention” and with it the traditional idea that according to the laws of nature seminal emissions sometimes might also have a beneficial effect on physical health. Rather than putrefying in the body, the semen was said to recirculate into the body after its preparation in the seminal vessels and served an indispensable re‐invigorating function. It was responsible for the typical masculine traits of the male body. Divine law and natural law now fully coincided.

Endocrinology's early historians (1889-1914) and the forgotten prehistory of testosterone

Developing Sex: From Recremental Semen to Developmental Endocrinology

"Sexual Development": Timing Puberty in German Enlightenment Medicine (1778-99)

Male hypogonadism--current concepts and trends

History of Puberty: Normal and Precocious

Types, norms, and normalisation: Hormone research and treatments in Italy, Argentina, and Brazil, c. 1900-50

Current concepts in aesthetic endocrinology

From the Gorgon's blood to Behring's Blutserumtherapie: A long path towards serum therapy

Contrasting selected reproductive challenges of today with those of antiquity--the past is prologue

[Early origins of a physician specializing in sexual medicine from the urological perspective : Max Marcuse (1877-1963)-"physician for skin and urinary diseases"]

The Search for the Causes of Common Hyperandrogenism, 1965 to circa 2015

Hormonal Basis of Biological Sex Differences in Human Athletic Performance

The Crime of Onan and the Laws of Nature. Religious and medical discourses on masturbation in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries

Androgens and spermatogenesis

Female ejaculation: An update on anatomy, history, and controversies

Gastrointestinal hormones: History, biology, and measurement

The late Greco-Roman and Byzantine contribution to the evolution of laboratory examinations of bodily excrement. Part 1: Urine, sperm, menses and stools

Normative Basal Values of Hormones and Proteins of Gonadal and Adrenal Functions from Birth to Adulthood

Endocrine assessment of impotence--pitfalls of measuring serum testosterone without sex-hormone-binding globulin

Androgens and male fertility

History of the Development of Knowledge about the Neuroendocrine Control of Ovulation—Recent Knowledge on the Molecular Background