Abstract:Problem definition: A growing number of firms are encouraging consumers to participate in “bring-your-own-container” (BYOC) behavior in which consumers bring their own reusable packaging to purchase and consume products, thus reducing single-use packaging waste. In this paper, we study the environmental implications of a firm’s BYOC implementation when considering its disposable packaging choice and communication strategy. Methodology/results: We build a stylized model to study a firm’s joint decisions on BYOC, disposable packaging choice, and communication and their implications on the environment. Our main results follow. First, allowing BYOC reduces the firm’s incentive to make fraudulent green claims about its disposable product packaging; however, BYOC implementation may harm the overall environment while improving the firm’s profit, thereby creating a new form of greenwashing. Second, the adoption of third-party certification for green disposable packaging is an effective remedy to mitigate the negative environmental impact of BYOC. In addition, the environmental implications of adopting third-party certification (either voluntarily or because of government mandates) depend on the relationship between the environmental qualities of green disposable packaging and reusable packaging. Whereas it always benefits the environment when the firm’s green disposable packaging has better environmental performance, adopting certification may negatively impact the environment if consumers’ reusable packaging is greener. Furthermore, we find numerically that offering a price discount for BYOC may encourage the firm to adopt certification because of increased profitability, thereby leading to the aforementioned environmental implications. Managerial implications: We offer operational insights on how firms should make joint decisions on BYOC, disposable packaging choice, and communication. We also generate insights on how governments should regulate firms’ green claims when firms start to allow BYOC. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2021.0605 .

A consumer attributions‐based approach for investigating the effect of corporate greenwashing on wishcycling

Green Disposable Packaging and Communication: the Implications of Bring-Your-Own-Container

Overthinking environmentally friendly? Need for cognition moderates the sustainability signal of natural patterns in biodegradable tableware

Environmental awareness, firm sustainability exposure and green consumption behaviors

Consumer Considerations for the Implementation of Sustainable Packaging: A Review

Incorporating Consumer Insights into the UK Food Packaging Supply Chain in the Transition to a Circular Economy

Consumers in the Circular Economy: A Path Analysis of the Underlying Factors of Purchasing Behaviour

Measuring antecedents of green consumption in a circular economy: An empirical study of household consumers for moral identity and pro-environmental self-accountability

Elucidating the Gap between Green Attitudes, Intentions, and Behavior through the Prism of Greenwashing Concerns

Understanding consumers' sustainability knowledge and behaviour towards food packaging to develop tailored consumer-centric engagement campaigns: A Greece and the United Kingdom perspective

Perceived Greenwashing and Its Impact on the Green Image of Brands

Corporate motivations for environmental sustainable development: exploring the role of consumers in stakeholder engagement

Consumer response to packaging design: The role of packaging materials and graphics in sustainability perceptions and product evaluations

How emotions and green altruism explain consumer purchase intention toward circular economy products: A multi‐group analysis on willingness to be environmentally friendly

Association of Consumer Behavior to a Circular Economy: Assessing a Variety of Perceptions and its Correlation in Germany

Behavioral spillover in the circular economy: The importance of consumer goals

Consumer Behaviour in a Circular System – How Values Promote and Hinder the Participation of Young Adults in the Swedish Deposit-Refund System for Beverage Packaging

The Dark Side of Environmental Sustainability in Projects: Unraveling Greenwashing Behaviors

Green Packaging or Greenwashing? Implications of Bring-Your-Own-Container

Social Cognitive Theory and Reciprocal Relationship: A Guide to Single-Use Plastic Education for Policymakers, Business Leaders and Consumers

Profit motives, environmental motives, and perceived corporate greenwashing revisited: A replication and extension of de Vries et al. (2015)