Identifying anthropogenic sources of groundwater contamination by natural background levels and stable isotope application in Pinggu basin, China

Jia Li,Zheming Shi,Mingzhu Liu,Guangcai Wang,Fei Liu,Yiling Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.126092
IF: 6.4
2021-05-01
Journal of Hydrology
Abstract:<p>The assessment of natural background levels (NBLs) in groundwater is considered as an efficient way to distinguish the geogenic compound from anthropogenic pollution of groundwater—a basic issue in groundwater environmental management. At present, most studies only assess NBLs of single parameters in groundwater. Such method, however, ignored the complex components and interaction in the groundwater, which leads to the inaccuracy of the assessment. In this study, 51 groundwater samples were investigated in November, 2018 in Pinggu basin—one of the most important emergency groundwater supply sources of Beijing. Hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) was used firstly to divide the study area into four zones. By combining single-parameter NBLs assessment and comprehensive NBLs assessment, the possible anthropogenic impact on groundwater quality in different zones could be determined with the use of land use map. For single-parameter NBLs assessment, iterative Grubbs' test was used to assess NBLs of the data following Gaussian distribution, and the median plus/minus twofold the median of the absolute deviations from the median (median±2MAD) method was used to assess NBLs of the data for the non-Gaussian distribution. For comprehensive NBLs assessment, Mahalanobis distances of scatters in scatter plots which express the hydrogeological evolution processes were involved. In addition, δ<sup>15</sup>N-NO<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> and δ<sup>18</sup>O-NO<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> were used to analyze the sources of nitrate in groundwater. The results showed that the groundwater was affected by industrial activities, agricultural activities, urban domestic sewage and landfills. And the groundwater quality in the east of the study area was better than that in the west. Nitrate in the groundwater of study area mainly came from nitrification, and denitrification occurred in the groundwater near the landfills. This study provides a way to assess the NBLs of groundwater quality, and to determine sources and transformation of nitrate in the groundwater, which contributes to the identification of anthropogenic pollution in groundwater.</p>
geosciences, multidisciplinary,water resources,engineering, civil
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the natural background levels (NBLs) in groundwater in order to distinguish the influence of geogenic compounds from anthropogenic pollution on groundwater. Specifically, the study aims to determine possible anthropogenic impacts in different regions by combining single - parameter NBLs evaluation and comprehensive NBLs evaluation methods, and use land - use maps to analyze these impacts. In addition, the study also uses stable isotopes (δ15N - NO_3 and δ18O - NO_3) to analyze the sources of nitrate in groundwater, so as to more accurately identify anthropogenic pollution sources. ### Main problems: 1. **Evaluating the natural background levels (NBLs) in groundwater**: - The study determines the natural background levels of different parameters through single - parameter NBLs evaluation and comprehensive NBLs evaluation, combined with statistical methods (such as iterative Grubbs test and median ± 2MAD method). - Hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) is used to divide the study area into four different regions in order to analyze the groundwater characteristics of each region more meticulously. 2. **Identifying anthropogenic pollution sources**: - By combining the analysis of land - use maps and groundwater chemical parameters, possible anthropogenic pollution sources in different regions are determined. - Stable isotopes (δ15N - NO_3 and δ18O - NO_3) are used to analyze the sources of nitrate to further confirm the nature of pollution sources. ### Specific objectives: - **Single - parameter NBLs evaluation**: - Use the pre - selection method to remove samples with high nitrate content. - Conduct a normality test (Shapiro - Wilk test) on the remaining data, and select an appropriate statistical method (such as Grubbs test or median ± 2MAD method) according to the data distribution to identify outliers. - Calculate the NBLs range of each parameter. - **Comprehensive NBLs evaluation**: - Evaluate the comprehensive NBLs through five classic groundwater chemical scatter plots (such as Chadha plot, CAI vs. Cl^- plot, NO3^-/Cl^- vs. Cl^- plot, HCO3^-/Cl^- vs. Cl^- plot and Ca2++Mg2+ vs. HCO3^- plot). - Use Mahalanobis distance to calculate the similarity of points in the scatter plots and further identify abnormal points. - **Stable isotope analysis**: - Use δ15N - NO_3 and δ18O - NO_3 to analyze the sources of nitrate and distinguish nitrates from different sources (such as atmospheric precipitation, synthetic fertilizers, soil nitrogen, sewage and manure). Through the above methods, the study aims to provide an effective method to evaluate the natural background levels of groundwater quality, determine the sources of nitrate and its biogeochemical transformation mechanisms, thereby helping to identify and manage the impact of anthropogenic pollution on groundwater.