The Mutational Road not Taken: Using Ancestral Sequence Resurrection to Evaluate the Evolution of Plant Enzyme Substrate Preferences

Emily M Catania,Nicole M Dubs,Shejal Soumen,Todd J Barkman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/gbe/evae016

2024-01-30

Genome Biology and Evolution

Abstract:Abstract We investigated the flowering plant salicylic acid methyl transferase (SAMT) enzyme lineage to understand the evolution of substrate preference change. Previous studies indicated that a single amino acid replacement to the SAMT active site (H150M) was sufficient to change ancestral enzyme substrate preference from benzoic acid to the structurally similar substrate, salicylic acid (SA). Yet, subsequent studies have shown that the H150M function-changing replacement did not likely occur during the historical episode of enzymatic divergence studied. Therefore, we reinvestigated the origin of SA methylation preference here and additionally assessed the extent to which epistasis may act to limit mutational paths. We found that the SAMT lineage of enzymes acquired preference to methylate SA from an ancestor that preferred to methylate benzoic acid as previously reported. In contrast, we found that a different amino acid replacement, Y267Q, was sufficient to change substrate preference with others providing small positive-magnitude epistatic improvements. We show that the kinetic basis for the ancestral enzymatic change in substate preference by Y267Q appears to be due to both a reduced specificity constant, kcat/KM, for benzoic acid and an improvement in KM for SA. Therefore, this lineage of enzymes appears to have had multiple mutational paths available to achieve the same evolutionary divergence. While the reasons remain unclear for why one path was taken, and the other was not, the mutational distance between ancestral and descendant codons may be a factor.

genetics & heredity,evolutionary biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This study investigates the substrate preference changes in the evolution of plant enzymes - S-adenosyl-L-methionine:anthocyanin 3-O-methyltransferase (SAMT). Through ancestral sequence resurrection, the research aims to understand the transition of SAMT enzymes from preferring benzoic acid to structurally similar salicylic acid. Previous studies suggested that a single amino acid substitution (H150M) is sufficient to alter the substrate preference of the enzyme, but subsequent research shows that this substitution may not have occurred during historical differentiation events.

The authors revisited this issue and found that another amino acid substitution (Y267Q) caused the change in substrate preference, and several other amino acid substitutions provided positive phenotypic enhancement. They discovered that the Y267Q substitution decreased the specificity constant (kcat/KM) for benzoic acid, while increasing the KM for salicylic acid, thereby increasing the methylation preference for salicylic acid. Although there could be multiple mutational paths leading to the same functional change, it is not clear why a specific path was chosen, possibly due to limitations in mutation order or the influence of genetic drift.

The study emphasizes the presence of multiple mutational paths in the evolution of protein function, but the reasons for selecting a particular path still require further investigation. This contributes to our understanding of the complexity and diversity of adaptive evolution in biology.