The Prevalence and Effects of Loneliness in the General Population, Lawyer Well-being, and a Survey of Law Students
Olivia Ash
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3390457
2019-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:PURPOSEThis paper explores loneliness in the general population and discusses how it may impact those within the legal profession, including law students. Specifically, this paper explores: (1) loneliness: what it is, who is lonely, and how it affects a person; (2) current research on well-being and loneliness in the legal profession; and (3) results from a loneliness survey of law students. To the author’s knowledge, this is the first research to explore loneliness in the legal profession and the first research analyzing results of a survey of law students' loneliness. BACKGROUND RESEARCH Loneliness is perceived isolation, an aversive, distressing emotion, a response to a mental state. It is subjective and refers to a deficiency in a person’s social relationships in terms of type, quality, or quantity related to a perceived need. The feeling of being alone is a palpable, discomforting sense of being “without.” Loneliness is distressing because social relationships are necessary; the average person spends approximately 80% of waking hours in the company of other people, and time with others is preferred to time alone. Research indicates the loneliest humans are the young and old, those in poor health, and the highly educated, most notably those in the fields of medicine and law. High levels of loneliness are associated with an increased risk of becoming physically ill over time. Loneliness is tethered to negative coping mechanisms such as poor health, heavy drinking, lack of work or study, and low income. Loneliness' impact on mental health is alarming. Loneliness is well documented among persons likely to be diagnosed as depressed but has not been a focus of research or mental health service delivery and policy. Lonely workers feel less satisfied with jobs, receive fewer promotions, switch jobs more often, lack social support in the workplace, and are more likely to quit within the next six months. America’s loneliest workers are single and childless, well-educated, more likely to work for the government, and occupationally, are led by lawyers and doctors, with lawyers reporting the highest levels of loneliness. Lawrence Krieger and Kennon Sheldon, confirmed in a 2002 study, that law students exhibit problems with emotional distress and substance abuse. Law school contributes to negative changes in values, motivations, and well-being, predicting decreased happiness and life satisfaction. In 2010, Martin and Rand published a study on hope and optimism among first year law students. Their research indicated “that law students begin their first year of law school with normal or even higher levels of well-being” than their undergraduate counterparts, but that well-being declines through the first year. In fact, research suggests “law school is a ‘breeding ground’ for depression, anxiety, and other stress-related illnesses.” DESIGN The author secured approval, including completion of Investigator training, from the Indiana University Internal Review Board (“IRB”) and the Office of Student Affairs (“OSA”) at the Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law (“School”) to send an electronic survey measuring loneliness (“Survey”) to its current law students. The Survey asks basic demographic and educational background questions; it also measures loneliness using the Revised UCLA Loneliness Scale (“Scale”). RESULTS56 students completed the Survey. Using the Scale score ranges, total loneliness scores (“Score(s)”) for Survey measures are as follows: a Score less than 28 is “Low” loneliness; a Score of 28-43 is “Moderate” loneliness; and a Score greater than 43 is “High” loneliness. First, cohort Scores ranged from 22 to 71; the mean Score was 43; and the most common Score was 40 (n=5), or high-moderate loneliness. Second, most respondents were white (n=51) and female (n=38). Third, as expected, most respondents have undergraduate degrees, but 23 percent have graduate degrees. Last, nearly all respondents are in the J.D. program (n=53), a majority are full-time students (n=36), and nearly 38% are second-year students. DISCUSSIONSurvey results suggest this cohort of law students: (1) scores, on average, one point from "highly lonely"; (2) shows little difference in Score between male and female respondents; and (3) aligns with research suggesting matriculating students report high loneliness. Why are lawyers reporting high levels of loneliness and are law students lonely? Lawyer well-being is an urgent topic; studies reveal the myriad detrimental physical and mental side effects due to the nature of the profession: high stress, higher rates than the general population for anxiety and depression, as well as high rates of suicide and substance use disorders. If loneliness rates are increasing among the general population, it is not a far reach to say lawyers’ loneliness is also increasing; therefore, research must be conducted examining the relationship between lawyers and loneliness.Unhealthy law students become unhealthy lawyers. How loneliness interacts with law student well-being concerns, e.g., anxiety, depression, and alcohol use, is yet to be measured. However, it stands to reason that if existing research indicates law student well-being is negatively affected, loneliness is likely to play a role in worsening health. What types of interventions to mitigate law student stress could be implemented in law schools? Research within the general population suggests “talk therapy” is most effective for mitigating loneliness. How can law schools, law firms, and even judicial systems support and apply this vital well-being tool for students and lawyers? These questions and more are ripe for the taking by energetic researchers.