Probabilistic justice against status defense: inequality, uncertainty, and the future of the welfare state

Rachel Z. Friedman,Torben Iversen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11186-024-09547-6
2024-04-10
Theory and Society
Abstract:The postwar welfare state provides social insurance against economic, health, and related risks in an uncertain world. Because everyone can envision themselves to be among the unfortunate, social insurance fuses self-interest and solidarism in a normative principle Friedman (2020) calls probabilistic justice. But there is a competing principle of status defense, where the aim is to erect boundaries between socioeconomic strata and discourage cross-class mobility. We argue that this principle dominates when inequality is high and uncertainty low. The current moment is one of high inequality and high uncertainty, which results in intense status anxiety, yet does not rule out solidaristic solutions. Our contributions are to diagnose the causes of our current malaise, and to theorize the normative bases for the political choice facing contemporary western democracies.
sociology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?