Developing a Project-Expectancy Inventory for the Construction Industry from the Owner's Perspective

Xin Wei,Liuying Zhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16072675
IF: 3.9
2024-03-26
Sustainability
Abstract:Although current research recognizes the importance of the Expectancy Theory in the construction industry, a standardized project expectancy (PE, hereafter) inventory is still an area for further exploration, especially from the owner's perspective. This inventory is essential to identify the owner's expectancy priorities and help select partners aligned with their long-term and sustainable project goals. Based on the Expectancy Theory, a PE inventory is proposed after conducting a comprehensive literature review. It incorporates dimensions like goal difficulty, perceived control, and self-efficacy. The reliability of the inventory is confirmed by analyzing data from 197 construction-project openers through partial least squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM, hereafter). The findings indicate that perceived control is the most crucial dimension in PE, followed by self-efficacy and goal difficulty. A tunneling construction megaproject in Southeast China is presented as a case study. It suggests that when selecting partners for construction projects, the project owner should prioritize those amenable to control, thereby enhancing teamwork and collaboration quality. This strategy emphasizes the importance of the owner's command over project operation, rather than merely focusing on the partners' capabilities.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of developing a systematic Project Expectancy (PE) checklist from the perspective of project owners in the construction industry. Specifically, the study aims to: 1. **Develop a Project Expectancy Checklist**: Based on Expectancy Theory, construct a checklist that can describe and measure the project expectations of owners in construction projects. 2. **Determine the Priorities of Project Owners' Expectations**: Identify which factors have the greatest impact on owners' project expectations through data analysis. 3. **Provide Management Solutions for Project Owners**: Help project owners better consider these expectation factors when selecting partners, thereby improving team cooperation quality and project success rates. ### Background and Motivation Current research recognizes the importance of Expectancy Theory in the construction industry but lacks a standardized Project Expectancy checklist, especially from the perspective of project owners. This leads many construction professionals to rely on intuition or fragmented methods to predict owners' expectations, potentially resulting in inefficiencies and conflicts. Therefore, developing such a checklist can more accurately assess and integrate owners' expectations, enhancing project planning and management effectiveness, and avoiding reliance on intuition or fragmented methods. ### Research Methods 1. **Literature Review**: Conduct a comprehensive review of existing literature to identify key factors and dimensions that constitute project expectations. 2. **Conceptual Framework Development**: Define key factors and constructs based on Expectancy Theory, ensuring relevance to current industry practices. 3. **Expert Consultation**: Invite industry experts to refine the conceptual checklist, making it more applicable to real-world scenarios. 4. **Questionnaire Survey**: Design a questionnaire to collect data from individuals involved in construction projects. 5. **Statistical Analysis**: Use IBM SPSS Statistics 26.0 and SmartPLS 4.0 for statistical analysis, including descriptive statistics, T-tests, ANOVA, and Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM). ### Main Findings 1. **Perceived Control**: In project expectations, perceived control is the most critical dimension, followed by self-efficacy and goal difficulty. 2. **Case Study**: A large tunnel construction project in Southeast China is used as a case study to demonstrate how prioritizing easily controllable partners can improve team cooperation and collaboration quality. 3. **Management Recommendations**: Emphasize that project owners should focus on controlling project operations, not just the capabilities of partners. ### Conclusion By developing a systematic Project Expectancy checklist, this study provides a structured tool for construction project owners, helping them better integrate and reflect their expectations in project planning and management, thereby increasing the likelihood of project success.