Efficiency Evaluation of Forest Carbon Sinks: A Case Study of Russia

Arsenii Vilkov,Gang Tian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/f15040649

IF: 3.282

2024-04-03

Forests

Abstract:Forest carbon sinks in Russia are an integral part of the national "Low-carbon development strategy". However, the influence of natural disasters and various land use policies in economic regions (ERs) raises the issue of forest carbon sink efficiency (FCSE). This study adopted a DEA-SBM model that considers undesirable outputs to measure FCSE, and the Malmquist index (MI) approach to analyze total factor productivity (TFP) of forest carbon sinks, using panel data from 2009 to 2021. The results show that the average FCSE was 0.788, with an improvement rate of 21.2%. Scale efficiency is the main factor constraining FCSE in Russia. In twelve ERs, forest carbon sinks are efficient only in the Kaliningrad and West Siberian ERs. In general, forest carbon sinks in Russia are inefficient mainly due to forest fires and other natural disturbances (82.33%); excessive logging activities (38.64%); and lack of carbon absorption capacity (31.70%). The average score of their TFP is 0.970, indicating a decline of 3% over the study period. This is primarily attributed to the decline of 1.6% in technological change. The productivity of forest carbon sinks remained static only in the Kaliningrad ER, while other economic regions performed deterioration trends. Therefore, Russia should enhance the efficiency of forest carbon sinks.

forestry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the efficiency of Russia's forest carbon sinks and analyze its total factor productivity (TFP). Specifically, the study adopts the DEA - SBM model considering undesirable outputs to measure the forest carbon sink efficiency (FCSE), and analyzes the changes in Russia's forest carbon sink TFP from 2009 to 2021 through the Malmquist index method. The main purposes of the study are:

1. **Evaluate the efficiency of Russia's forest carbon sinks**: By introducing undesirable outputs (such as forest fire area and logging area), more comprehensively evaluate the efficiency of forest carbon sinks.
2. **Analyze the changes in total factor productivity**: Use the Malmquist index method to analyze the productivity changes of forest carbon sinks in different time periods.
3. **Identify the factors affecting the efficiency of forest carbon sinks**: Explore the impacts of natural disasters, human activities and other factors on the efficiency of forest carbon sinks.
4. **Put forward improvement suggestions**: Based on the evaluation results, provide policy suggestions for improving the efficiency of Russia's forest carbon sinks.

The research results show that the average efficiency value of Russia's forest carbon sinks is 0.788, with a 21.2% room for improvement. Scale efficiency is the main factor restricting the efficiency of forest carbon sinks. Among the 12 economic regions, only the Kaliningrad and West Siberian economic regions have efficient forest carbon sinks. Overall, forest fires and other natural disasters (accounting for 82.33%), excessive logging activities (accounting for 38.64%) and lack of carbon absorption capacity (accounting for 31.70%) are the main reasons for the low efficiency of Russia's forest carbon sinks. In addition, the study also found that from 2009 to 2021, the average TFP of Russia's forest carbon sinks was 0.970, indicating that TFP decreased by 3% during this period.

Therefore, this study aims to fill the research gap in the evaluation of Russia's forest carbon sink efficiency and provide scientific basis and policy suggestions for improving the efficiency of forest carbon sinks.