Late time dynamics of scalar perturbations outside black holes: I. A shell toy-model

Leor Barack
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.59.044016
1998-11-10
Abstract:We present a new analytic approach for the study of late time evolution of linear test-fields, propagating on the exterior of black holes. This method provides a calculation scheme applicable to Kerr black holes (for which case no analytic calculation of the late time tails has been presented so far). In this paper we develop the new technique and apply it to the case of massless scalar waves evolving on the background geometry of a static spherically-symmetric thin shell with a Schwarzschild exterior. The late time behavior of the scalar field at null infinity is calculated, and is explicitly related to the form of (quite arbitrary) initial data. This reproduces the well-known late time power-law decaying tails. In an accompanying paper we apply our approach to the complete Schwarzschild black hole geometry, where we obtain the familiar inverse-power late time tails at null infinity, as well as at time-like infinity and along the event horizon. A calculation of the late time power-law tails in the Kerr geometry, based on the same approach, will be presented in a forthcoming paper.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the behavior of scalar perturbations outside black holes at late times. Specifically, the author proposes a new analytical method to study the late - time evolution of linear test fields (such as massless scalar waves) in the background outside black holes. This method is especially suitable for Kerr black holes, because there has been no analytical calculation of the late - time tail of Kerr black holes before. ### Main problems of the paper: 1. **Analytical calculation of late - time behavior**: How to analytically calculate the late - time behavior of massless scalar waves in the background of a static spherically symmetric thin - shell, and explicitly relate it to the form of the initial data. 2. **Scope of application**: Whether this method can be applied to more complex black - hole geometries, especially Kerr black holes. 3. **Verification of known results**: Verify the effectiveness of this method through simple models (such as thin - shell toy models), and compare it with existing numerical and analytical results. 4. **Extended application**: Explore the applicability of this method in other curvature geometries, especially the scalar - wave dynamics in non - asymptotically flat backgrounds. ### Specific objectives: - **Development of analytical methods**: Develop an analytical method that can handle the late - time behavior of scalar waves in the background of Kerr black holes. - **Application of simplified models**: Demonstrate the applicability and effectiveness of this method through a simplified thin - shell toy model. - **Calculation of late - time tails**: Calculate the late - time behavior of scalar waves at null infinity, and verify that it conforms to the known power - law decay tail characteristics. - **Further expansion**: Discuss the application prospects of this method in the complete Schwarzschild black - hole geometry and other backgrounds. ### Method overview: 1. **Characteristic initial - value problem**: Express the evolution problem of scalar waves as a characteristic initial - value problem, with initial data defined on two characteristic (null) surfaces. 2. **Iterative expansion**: Introduce an iterative expansion method, decompose the wave function into multiple components, and each component satisfies a recurrence relation. 3. **Green's function technique**: Use the standard Green's function technique to solve each component in the iterative expansion. 4. **Calculation of late - time behavior**: Through the above methods, calculate the late - time behavior of scalar waves at null infinity, and verify that it conforms to the known power - law decay characteristics. ### Conclusions: - This method successfully analytically calculates the late - time behavior of scalar waves in the background of a static spherically symmetric thin - shell. - Through a simple thin - shell toy model, the effectiveness of this method is verified. - This method can be applied to more complex Kerr black - hole backgrounds, providing a basis for further research. ### Formula examples: - **Decomposition of wave function**: \[ \Psi=\Psi_0 + \Psi_1+\Psi_2+\cdots \] - **Iterative relation**: \[ \Psi_{N,uv}+V_0\Psi_N = \begin{cases} 0 & \text{if } N = 0 \\ -(\delta V)\Psi_{N - 1} & \text{if } N>0 \end{cases} \] - **Initial conditions**: \[ \Psi_N(u = u_0)=0\quad(\forall N\geq0) \] \[ \Psi_N(v = 0)= \begin{cases} \Gamma(u) & \text{if } N = 0 \\ 0 & \text{if } N>0 \end{cases} \] - **Boundary conditions**: \[ \Psi_N(r^* = 0)=0\quad(\forall N\geq0) \] These formulas show the mathematical tools and techniques used in the paper, ensuring the accuracy and readability of the calculations.