Unravelling the 'collective' in sociotechnical imaginaries: A literature review

Magdalena Kuchler,Gubb Marit Stigson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2024.103422

IF: 8.514

2024-02-02

Energy Research & Social Science

Abstract:The concept of sociotechnical imaginaries (STI) has been increasingly implemented in social science energy research to examine collectively held visions of desirable energy futures. In this paper, we attempt to make sense of the notion of a 'collective' central to the STI approach. We do so by performing a literature review of 69 peer-reviewed empirical articles that specifically delve into STIs concerning energy systems and transitions. We ask how 'collective' or 'collectively held imaginary' is defined and mobilised in these studies and what methods and empirical material scholars employ to access it analytically. Our literature review reveals a predominant emphasis on national collectives, frequently serving as the primary lens for analysis, with studies also exploring the interplay between national and local/regional STIs. Beyond the nation-state, we find instances of research delving into local/regional collectives and internationally or transnationally held STIs. Moreover, we illustrate how the choice of a specific 'collective' entry point influences methodological choices. Drawing from our literature review, we call for a more critical and comprehensive engagement with the notion of a 'collective' to elucidate how and why specific STIs gain prominence and power or lose acceptance and are marginalised within various collectives, especially in the context of low-carbon energy transitions. We further urge STI scholars to focus on diverse collectives that contribute to a sense of belonging beyond the confines of scale and place, such as class, gender, race, or ethnicity. Additionally, we emphasise the role of individuals, including those less socially prominent, in (re)shaping energy imaginaries.

environmental studies