EBV specific antibody‐based and DNA‐based assays in serologic diagnosis of nasopharyngeal carcinoma

K. Chan,Yao-Liang Gu,Fai W. Ng,P. Ng,W. Seto,J. Sham,D. Chua,W. Wei,Yue-Long Chen,W. Luk,Y. Zong,M. Ng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ijc.11130
2003-07-10
International Journal of Cancer
Abstract:We assessed 5 EBV specific assays for their capacity to effect serologic diagnosis of suspected NPC. The assays were the immunofluorescent assays, VCA IgA and EA IgA, the enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assays specific for EBNA 1 IgA or zta IgG and an EBV DNA assay. Serum samples were taken from 218 symptomatic NPC patients presenting consecutively at a public hospital in Hong Kong, 51 of whom were subsequently diagnosed as having NPC; 4 had EBV‐associated lung cancer with similar serology as NPC. The remaining patients included 23 who had other cancers and 140 who had other diseases. Objectives of serodiagnosis under such clinical settings, therefore, are to both exclude and predict a diagnosis of NPC. None of the assays individually can meet both requirements adequately, however. The difficulty was best overcome by combining EBNA 1 IgA and zta IgG. It was shown that 68.3% of the patients gave a confirmed test results, negative or positive, by both tests. A confirmed negative result was associated with a negative predictive value of 99.1%, providing a clear indication to exclude a diagnosis of NPC; a confirmed positive result was associated with a positive predictive value of 86.8%, providing a clear indication to proceed with diagnostic work‐up of NPC. The remaining patients gave equivocal test results, being positive for one or the other test, which were associated with a positive predictive value of 43.3% and 24.2%, respectively. © 2003 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the understanding of the production mechanism of charm mesons (i.e., particles containing a charm quark and an anti - charm quark, collectively referred to as "charmonium") in different experimental environments (such as Tevatron, HERA, and LHC). Specifically, the paper focuses on how to explain the inconsistency between the color - octet matrix elements obtained from Tevatron data and those extracted from HERA data by considering the high - order effects of initial - state gluon radiation. In addition, the paper also attempts to estimate the cross - section of muon events from directly produced J/ψ mesons as a background source for the B - physics program in LHC experiments. ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **Solving the inconsistency in the color - octet model**: - The authors believe that the inconsistency between the color - octet matrix elements previously extracted from Tevatron and HERA data may be due to the neglect of the intrinsic transverse momentum of partons (i.e., the influence of initial - state radiation). By introducing this factor, the authors re - evaluated these matrix elements and found that the new values are more consistent with the results of HERA. 2. **Predictions for LHC experiments**: - Based on the color - octet model and an improved PYTHIA simulation, the authors made predictions for the cross - section of directly produced J/ψ mesons in LHC experiments and estimated the cross - section of the resulting muon events. These predictions are of great significance for B - physics research in LHC experiments, especially for the search for the golden - standard decay mode of CP violation \( B_0^d \rightarrow J/\psi K_s \). ### Technical details - **Influence of initial - state radiation**: - The authors used PYTHIA to simulate the influence of multi - gluon emission and found that this would cause events to migrate to the high - \( p_t \) tail, thereby enhancing the differential cross - section in the high - \( p_t \) region. - **Theoretical uncertainties**: - The authors discussed various theoretical uncertainties when extracting color - octet matrix elements, including the choice of energy scale, quark mass, parton distribution functions (PDF), etc. - **Specific results of LHC predictions**: - The authors gave the estimated cross - section values of muon events satisfying specific pseudo - rapidity and transverse - momentum cut conditions in LHC experiments: \[ \sigma(\mu_3) = 622 \text{ nb} \] \[ \sigma(\mu_6) = 52 \text{ nb} \] \[ \sigma(\mu_3\mu_3) = 30 \text{ nb} \] \[ \sigma(\mu_6\mu_3) = 9 \text{ nb} \] ### Conclusion This paper solves the inconsistency problem of the color - octet model between different experimental data by introducing the influence of initial - state radiation and provides important background estimates for B - physics research in LHC experiments. These results are helpful for a better understanding of the dynamics of strong interactions, especially the charmonium production mechanism in high - energy collisions.