A New Astrophysical Interpretation of the Si and Ti Isotopic Compositions of Mainstream SiC Grains from Primitive Meteorites

Maria Lugaro,Roberto Gallino,Maurizio Busso,Sachiko Amari,Ernst Zinner
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/9809212
1998-09-17
Abstract:Mainstream presolar SiC grains from primitive meteorites show a clear s-process signature in the isotopic composition of heavy trace elements. These grains most likely condensed in the winds of a variety of AGB stars. However, the non-solar and correlated Si and Ti isotopic compositions measured in these grains are inconsistent with a pure s-signature. We present a possible solution to this much-discussed problem by assuming a spread in the original composition of parent AGB stars due to small chemical inhomogeneities in the interstellar medium at the time of their birth. These inhomogeneities may naturally arise from variations in the contributions of each nuclide to the interstellar medium by the relevant stellar nucleosynthetic sites, SNII and different subtypes of SNIa.
Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explain the inconsistency between the silicon (Si) and titanium (Ti) isotope compositions of the mainstream silicon carbide (SiC) grains in primitive meteorites and the prediction results of the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) star evolution model. ### Problem Background 1. **Differences between AGB Star Model Predictions and Observation Data**: - Mainstream presolar SiC grains show obvious s - process characteristics, indicating that they may condense in the winds of various AGB stars. - However, the non - solar and correlated Si and Ti isotope compositions of these grains are inconsistent with the pure s - process characteristics. Specifically, the variation range of the measured Si and Ti isotope ratios is much larger than the predicted values of the AGB star envelopes. 2. **The Specialties of Si and Ti Isotopes**: - For Si, the s - process has a relatively small impact on its isotope abundances in the helium shell of AGB stars because the neutron - capture cross - section of light elements is low. - The situation is similar for Ti isotopes, especially for the heavier 49Ti and 50Ti isotopes, which are more easily produced by neutron capture. ### Proposed Solution The author proposes a possible explanation: assume that there are small chemical inhomogeneities in the interstellar medium (ISM) at the birth of AGB stars. These inhomogeneities may be caused by the different contributions of type II supernovae (SNII) and different subtypes of type Ia supernovae (SNIa) to the ISM. ### Specific Methods 1. **Model Calculation**: - Starting from an ISM with solar composition, perturb the ISM by introducing small (positive and negative) contributions from three main stellar sources. - The calculation formula is: \[ X_i = X_{i\odot} + \sum_{j = 1}^{3}a_jM_{ij} \] where \(X_i\) is the mass fraction of isotope \(i\), \(X_{i\odot}\) is the reference value of the solar composition, \(M_{ij}\) is the mass of isotope \(i\) released by the \(j\)-th type of stellar source (in solar masses), and \(a_j\) represents the contribution level of each source, ranging from \(- 0.0004M_\odot^{-1}\) to \(+0.0004M_\odot^{-1}\). 2. **Result Analysis**: - The calculated δ values (deviations of isotope ratios relative to solar values, expressed in parts per thousand) were compared with the δ values of individual SiC grains actually measured. - The results show that the model considering ISM inhomogeneities can better explain the large - range variations of the observed Si and Ti isotope compositions. ### Conclusion By assuming that there are small local inhomogeneities in the ISM, it can be explained why the Si and Ti isotope compositions of mainstream SiC grains show a large variation range instead of being as narrow as predicted by the AGB star model. This explanation is applicable not only to Si but also to Ti, and it helps to understand the contributions of different stellar sources in the chemical evolution process of the Milky Way. In addition, the author also mentions that a complete astrophysical explanation also needs to include a small number of special SiC grains (such as SiC - Y and SiC - Z), whose isotope compositions are different from those of mainstream grains.