An Isocurvature Mechanism for Structure Formation

Wayne Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.59.021301

1998-09-11

Abstract:We examine a novel mechanism for structure formation involving initial number density fluctuations between relativistic species, one of which then undergoes a temporary downward variation in its equation of state and generates superhorizon-scale density fluctuations. Isocurvature decaying dark matter models (iDDM) provide concrete examples. This mechanism solves the phenomenological problems of traditional isocurvature models, allowing iDDM models to fit the current CMB and large-scale structure data, while still providing novel behavior. We characterize the decaying dark matter and its decay products as a single component of ``generalized dark matter''. This simplifies calculations in decaying dark matter models and others that utilize this mechanism for structure formation.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve several key problems in the traditional isocurvature models in the theory of structure formation, especially the inconsistencies between these models and the current cosmic microwave background (CMB) and large - scale structure observational data. Specifically, these problems include:

1. **Relatively Insufficient Large - Scale Structure**: The large - scale structure predicted by traditional isocurvature models is insufficient relative to the large - angle CMB anisotropy.
2. **Weakening of Acoustic Peaks**: The small - angle acoustic peaks predicted by traditional isocurvature models are weaker, which is inconsistent with the observations.

To solve these problems, the author proposes a new isocurvature mechanism, which generates density fluctuations on super - horizon scales by introducing initial number density fluctuations. The core of this mechanism lies in a model called "interacting decaying dark matter" (iDDM), in which dark matter undergoes a brief equation - of - state variation, thereby generating structures.

### Specific Mechanism

1. **Initial Conditions**:
- In the initial state, there are number density fluctuations among relativistic species, and one of the species then experiences a temporary decrease in the equation of state, generating density fluctuations on super - horizon scales.
- Under isocurvature conditions, the initial stress - energy tensor is completely homogeneous and isotropic.

2. **Equation - of - State Change**:
- The dark matter species changes from a relativistic state to a non - relativistic state and then decays into a radiative state. The equation of state \( w_{\text{ddm}} \) drops from \( \frac{1}{3} \) to close to zero and then returns to \( \frac{1}{3} \).

3. **Curvature Generation**:
- When dark matter becomes non - relativistic, the initially balanced stress fluctuations become unbalanced, forming density or curvature fluctuations.
- When dark matter decays into radiation, the stress is re - balanced and the formation of curvature fluctuations stops.
- The evolution of curvature \( \zeta \) is described by the following formula:
\[
\zeta(a)=\frac{\sigma}{3(p_{\text{ddm}}+\rho_{\text{ddm}})}\big|_{a_0}+\zeta(0),
\]
where \( \sigma = \left( \frac{\delta \rho_{\text{ddm}}}{\rho_{\text{ddm}}+p_{\text{ddm}}}-\frac{\delta \rho_r}{\rho_r + p_r} \right)\big|_0 \), and \( a \) is the scale factor.

4. **Improvements**:
- This mechanism solves the problems of traditional isocurvature models in terms of the CMB acoustic peaks and the relative magnitudes of large - scale structures.
- It allows the iDDM model to be consistent with the current CMB and large - scale structure data and provides novel behavioral characteristics.

### Conclusion

The isocurvature mechanism proposed in this paper solves the problems existing in traditional isocurvature models by introducing a specific dark matter decay process. This mechanism can not only explain the current observational data but also provide new testable features for future experiments. In addition, it reminds us not to over - interpret the existing data and encourages the exploration of new paradigms of structure formation.