Abstract:Financial markets are a quintessential example of complex systems wherein strategic connections arising through the trading (buying and selling) of different stocks gives rise to dynamic correlation patterns in stock prices. Network science based approaches have been employed for more than two decades to investigate the stock market as an inferential network, with nodes representing stocks and edges as pairwise cross-correlations between stock prices. However, a recent focus has been the characterization of the higher-order structure, beyond pairwise correlation, of such networks. To this end, geometry-inspired measures (such as discrete Ricci curvatures) and topological data analysis (TDA) based methods (such as persistent homology) have become attractive tools for characterizing the higher-order structure of networks representing the financial systems. In this study, our goal is to perform a comparative analysis of both these approaches, especially by assessing the fragility and systemic risk in the Indian stock markets, which is known for its high volatility and risk. To achieve this goal, we analyze the time series of daily log-returns of stocks comprising the National Stock Exchange (NSE) and the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE). Specifically, our aim is to monitor the changes in standard network measures, edge-centric discrete Ricci curvatures, and persistent homology based topological measures computed from cross-correlation matrices of stocks. In this study, the edge-centric discrete Ricci curvatures have been employed for the first time in the analysis of the Indian stock markets. The Indian stock markets are known to be less diverse in comparison to the US market, and hence provides us an interesting example. Our results point that, among the persistent homology based topological measures, persistent entropy is simple and more robust than L1 -norm and L2 -norm of persistence landscape. In a broader comparison between network analysis and TDA, we highlight that the network analysis is sensitive to the way of constructing the networks (threshold or minimum spanning tree), as well as the threshold values used to construct the correlation-based threshold networks. On the other hand, the persistent homology is a more robust approach and is able to capture the higher-order interactions and eliminate noisy data in financial systems, since it does not take into account a single value of threshold but rather a range of values.

Hierarchical Structure in Financial Markets

Topology of foreign exchange markets using hierarchical structure methods

Topological structures in the equities market network

Correlation, hierarchies, and networks in financial markets

Relation between Financial Market Structure and the Real Economy: Comparison between Clustering Methods

Hierarchical structure in phonographic market

Hierarchical representation of socio-economic complex systems according to minimal sapnning trees

Hierarchical structure of stock price fluctuations in financial markets

Topology data analysis of critical transitions in financial networks

Carbon-dioxide emissions trading and hierarchical structure in worldwide finance and commodities markets

Hierarchical Structure of the Foreign Trade: The Case of the United State

Hierarchical Causality in Financial Economics

Investigation of Indian stock markets using topological data analysis and geometry-inspired network measures

Complexities in Financial Network Topological Dynamics: Modeling of Emerging and Developed Stock Markets

A Topological Based Feature Extraction Method for the Stock Market

Structure and causality relations in a global network of financial companies

Higher-order clustering patterns in simplicial financial systems

Financial ratios and stock returns reappraised through a topological data analysis lens

Unveiling correlations between financial variables and topological metrics of trading networks: Evidence from a stock and its warrant

Topology of the correlation networks among major currencies using hierarchical structure methods