Abstract:Background: The promise of real-world evidence and the learning health care system primarily depends on access to high-quality data. Despite widespread awareness of the prevalence and potential impacts of poor data quality (DQ), best practices for its assessment and improvement are unknown. Objective: This review aims to investigate how existing research studies define, assess, and improve the quality of structured real-world health care data. Methods: A systematic literature search of studies in the English language was implemented in the Embase and PubMed databases to select studies that specifically aimed to measure and improve the quality of structured real-world data within any clinical setting. The time frame for the analysis was from January 1945 to June 2023. We standardized DQ concepts according to the Data Management Association (DAMA) DQ framework to enable comparison between studies. After screening and filtering by 2 independent authors, we identified 39 relevant articles reporting DQ improvement initiatives. Results: The studies were characterized by considerable heterogeneity in settings and approaches to DQ assessment and improvement. Affiliated institutions were from 18 different countries and 18 different health domains. DQ assessment methods were largely manual and targeted completeness and 1 other DQ dimension. Use of DQ frameworks was limited to the Weiskopf and Weng (3/6, 50%) or Kahn harmonized model (3/6, 50%). Use of standardized methodologies to design and implement quality improvement was lacking, but mainly included plan-do-study-act (PDSA) or define-measure-analyze-improve-control (DMAIC) cycles. Most studies reported DQ improvements using multiple interventions, which included either DQ reporting and personalized feedback (24/39, 61%), IT-related solutions (21/39, 54%), training (17/39, 44%), improvements in workflows (5/39, 13%), or data cleaning (3/39, 8%). Most studies reported improvements in DQ through a combination of these interventions. Statistical methods were used to determine significance of treatment effect (22/39, 56% times), but only 1 study implemented a randomized controlled study design. Variability in study designs, approaches to delivering interventions, and reporting DQ changes hindered a robust meta-analysis of treatment effects. Conclusions: There is an urgent need for standardized guidelines in DQ improvement research to enable comparison and effective synthesis of lessons learned. Frameworks such as PDSA learning cycles and the DAMA DQ framework can facilitate this unmet need. In addition, DQ improvement studies can also benefit from prioritizing root cause analysis of DQ issues to ensure the most appropriate intervention is implemented, thereby ensuring long-term, sustainable improvement. Despite the rise in DQ improvement studies in the last decade, significant heterogeneity in methodologies and reporting remains a challenge. Adopting standardized frameworks for DQ assessment, analysis, and improvement can enhance the effectiveness, comparability, and generalizability of DQ improvement initiatives.

Data Quality Improvement Strategies for Data Analysis Specific to the IT Industry

Research and development on data quality assessment management system

Data Quality Assessment: Challenges and Opportunities

Improving Data Quality in Clinical Research Informatics Tools

Data quality assessment and improvement

Analysis of Data Quality Problems in the Digital Hospital and Relevant Solutions

Data Quality Over Quantity: Pitfalls and Guidelines for Process Analytics

Problems and Systematic Solutions in Data Quality

Overview and Importance of Data Quality for Machine Learning Tasks

Big Data Quality: A Survey

Data Quality Evaluation: Methodology and Key Factors.

A Review of the State of the Art of Data Quality in Healthcare

Factors influencing enterprise to improve data quality in information systems application - An empirical research on 185 enterprises through field study

Data Quality-Driven Improvement in Health Care: Systematic Literature Review

Data Quality for AI Tool: Exploratory Data Analysis on IBM API

A Simplified Approach for Quality Management in Data Warehouse

Quality Analytics in a Big Data supply chain: Commodity data analytics for quality engineering

Improving data quality control in quality improvement projects

Data Quality Awareness: A Journey from Traditional Data Management to Data Science Systems

Drilling data quality improvement and information extraction with case studies

The challenges and opportunities of continuous data quality improvement for healthcare administration data