Toward High-Voltage Aqueous Batteries: Super- or Low-Concentrated Electrolyte?
Dongliang Chao,Shi-Zhang Qiao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2020.07.023
IF: 46.048
2020-01-01
Joule
Abstract:Graphical AbstractView Large Image Figure ViewerDownload Hi-res image Download (PPT) Recent incidents in organic media-based Li-ion batteries (LIBs), such as the Boeing 787 battery fires in 2013, Samsung Note 7 explosions in 2016, and the Tesla Model S combustions in 2019, have caused severe threats to human health and life. This is an alert that safety is a vital prerequisite for next-generation rechargeable batteries for both consumable electronics and electric vehicles. In this content, aqueous batteries (ABs) offer tremendous competitiveness in terms of safe operation, low cost, and facile manufacturing and recycling, together with high power density and tolerance against misuse. We have witnessed the prosperity of various types of rechargeable ABs in the market, such as primary Zn-Mn alkaline, valve-regulated lead-acid (VRLA), nickel-cadmium (Ni-Cd), and nickel-metal hydride (Ni-MH) batteries. These batteries possess competitiveness in economical profit, safety, or environmental influence. However, the market share has been continuously shrinking because of the inadequate energy density of ABs compared with the mainstream LIBs. Fundamentally, water has the thermodynamic potentials for oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) (Figure 1; Equations 1, 2, 3, and 4). The electrochemical stability window (ESW, potential difference between OER and HER) of water is ∼1.23 V, which restrains the operating output voltage of ABs and leads to insufficient energy density. Moreover, the generation of gases (H2, O2, etc.) consumes electrons and electrolyte, destroys the structure of the electrodes, and results in battery swell and inferior cycling stability. To overcome these issues and achieve better performance of ABs, it is crucial to suppress the water splitting and extend the ESW. Practically, the output voltage (E) is generally higher than 1.23 V (see Figure 1) because of the sluggish kinetics of HER (in acidic media: 2H++2e–→H2; in neutral or alkaline media: 2H2O+2e–→H2+2OH–) and OER (in acidic media:H2O→2H++12O2+2e–; in neutral or alkaline media: 2OH–→H2O+12O2+2e–) and the corresponding overpotentials (η), including the anode (ηa) and cathode (ηc) overpotentials from the intrinsic activation barriers and other overpotentials (ηo) from the solution and interface resistances, etc. Taking water activity into consideration (especially in the concentrated electrolyte, the equilibrium constant would vary with the water activity), the corresponding environmental potentials according to Nernst equations and related output voltage can be expressed as:forϕHER:ϕH+/H2=ϕH+/H2Θ+RTnFlnαH+2PH2/P0(Equation 1) ϕH2O/H2=ϕH2O/H2Θ+RTnFlnαH2O2αOH−2PH2/P0(Equation 2) forϕOER:ϕH2O/O2=ϕH2O/O2Θ+RTnFlnαH2O2αH+4PO2/P0(Equation 3) ϕOH−/O2=ϕOH−/O2Θ+RTnFlnαOH−4αH2O2PO2/P0(Equation 4) Outputvoltage:E=ϕOER−ϕHER+ηa+ηc+ηo(Equation 5) where the ϕH+/H2Θ and are the standard potential of HER; ϕH2O/O2Θ and ϕOH−/O2Θare the standard potential of OER; ϕH+/H2, ϕH2O/H2, ϕH2O/O2, and ϕOH−/O2represent the corresponding environmental potentials; αH2O, αH+, and αOH− correspond to the activities of water, H+, and OH– in electrolyte, respectively; PH2/P0 and PO2/P0 are partial pressures of hydrogen and oxygen, respectively; R, T, F, and n are thermodynamic constant, temperature, Faraday constant, and number of electrons, respectively. Widening the ESW of water has not only significantly boosted the viability of ABs in energy storage industry but also brought untouched chemistries and broadened the scope of materials selection. Super-concentrated electrolytes (SCEs) have been proven effective in extending the ESW but at the expense of high cost and confined reaction kinetics. Recent achievements in introducing competitive redox couples, optimizing current collectors, and applying pH decoupling with ion-selective membrane provide new opportunities in low-concentrated electrolytes (LCEs). Here, we summarize the strategies toward high-voltage ABs from a distinct perspective of different battery components. Critical appraisal is first raised regarding being super- or low-concentrated electrolyte in solving the voltage issue. We stress that SCE or LCE for high-voltage ABs should be compromised with the affordability, stability, and gravimetric/volumetric energy and power densities, when large-scale practical applications are considered. Finally, we render insights properly for future development of high-voltage ABs. In the past few years, advanced H/Li/Na/K/Zn-based ABs have garnered enormous interests worldwide.1Chao D. Zhou W. Xie F. Ye C. Li H. Jaroniec M. Qiao S.-Z. Roadmap for Advanced Aqueous Batteries: From Design of Materials to Applications.Sci. Adv. 2020; 6: eaba4098Crossref PubMed Scopus (180) Google Scholar,2Liu Z. Huang Y. Huang Y. Yang Q. Li X. Huang Z. et al.Voltage Issue of Aqueous Rechargeable Metal-Ion Batteries.Chem. Soc. Rev. 2020; 49: 180-232Crossref PubMed Google Scholar According to the Nernst equations and the electrochemical principles of water decomposition, the overpotentials are tunable via the temperature, pH value, concentration of electrolytes, and the interface effects (Figure 1; Equations 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5). Several strategies have been implemented effectively in inhibiting water activity and extending the ESW, such as redox-active additives, “water-in-salt” (WIS) electrolyte, hydrated eutectic electrolyte, and molecular crowding strategy.1Chao D. Zhou W. Xie F. Ye C. Li H. Jaroniec M. Qiao S.-Z. Roadmap for Advanced Aqueous Batteries: From Design of Materials to Applications.Sci. Adv. 2020; 6: eaba4098Crossref PubMed Scopus (180) Google Scholar,3Yang W. Du X. Zhao J. Chen Z. Li J. Xie J. Zhang Y. Cui Z. Kong Q. Zhao Z. et al.Hydrated Eutectic Electrolytes with Ligand-Oriented Solvation Shells for Long-Cycling Zinc-Organic Batteries.Joule. 2020; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2020.1005.1018Crossref Google Scholar Here, we summarize the key strategies toward high-voltage ABs in a special perspective of different battery components (Figure 2). As shown in the schematic, an aqueous cell consists of four main components: electrode (cathode and anode redox couples), electrolyte (solvent and solute), separator, and current collector. It is believed that all these components can be designed to contribute to high-voltage output in ABs. For example, from the perspective of the solute of electrolyte, Wang and co-workers proposed an effective SCE of WIS approach to extend the ESW of aqueous Li-ion batteries.4Suo L. Borodin O. Gao T. Olguin M. Ho J. Fan X. et al.“Water-in-Salt” Electrolyte Enables High-Voltage Aqueous Lithium-Ion Chemistries.Science. 2015; 350: 938-943Crossref PubMed Scopus (1278) Google Scholar, 5Borodin O. Self J. Persson K.A. Wang C. Xu K. Uncharted Waters: Super-Concentrated Electrolytes.Joule. 2020; 4: 69-100Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (78) Google Scholar, 6Yang C. Chen J. Ji X. Pollard T.P. Lü X. Sun C.J. et al.Aqueous Li-Ion Battery Enabled by Halogen Conversion-Intercalation Chemistry in Graphite.Nature. 2019; 569: 245-250Crossref PubMed Scopus (235) Google Scholar By super-concentrated solute of lithium bis(trifluuoromethane sulfonimide) (LiTFSI, 21 mol kg–1 [abbreviated as m]), a broadened ESW of ∼3.0 V has been realized in a Mo6S8//LiMn2O4 full cell (Figure 3).4Suo L. Borodin O. Gao T. Olguin M. Ho J. Fan X. et al.“Water-in-Salt” Electrolyte Enables High-Voltage Aqueous Lithium-Ion Chemistries.Science. 2015; 350: 938-943Crossref PubMed Scopus (1278) Google Scholar Compared to traditional aqueous electrolytes, a highly concentrated solute can decrease the number of free water molecules because of strengthened interaction between anions/cations and water. However, the use of super-concentrated fluorinated solutes, including LiTFSI, lithiumtrifluoromethane sulfolate (LiOTF), and lithium bis(pentafluoroethanesulfonyl)imide (LiBETI), will significantly increase the toxicity and cost on account of the excess reaction-irrelevant ions, which compromises the economic benefits, reduces the specific energy, and plagues the large-scale viability of ABs. Other low-cost and eco-friendly approaches to extend the ESW are indispensable.Figure 3Extension of the ESW of Aqueous BatteriesShow full caption(Left) Redox potentials of available redox couples that may be suitable for new ABs with extended ESW.(Right) The competitive redox couples refer to Zn/Zn2+ and MnO2/Mn2+ redox couples at anode and cathode, respectively, in 1 mol/L ZnSO4 + 1 mol/L MnSO4 electrolyte.7Chao D. Zhou W. Ye C. Zhang Q. Chen Y. Gu L. Davey K. Qiao S.Z. An Electrolytic Zn-MnO2 Battery for High-Voltage and Scalable Energy Storage.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2019; 58: 7823-7828Crossref PubMed Scopus (301) Google Scholar The “water-in-salt” corresponds to a super-concentrated solute of 21 m LiTFSI electrolyte in Mo6S8//LiMn2O4 cell4Suo L. Borodin O. Gao T. Olguin M. Ho J. Fan X. et al.“Water-in-Salt” Electrolyte Enables High-Voltage Aqueous Lithium-Ion Chemistries.Science. 2015; 350: 938-943Crossref PubMed Scopus (1278) Google Scholar or super-concentrated solute of sugar in sodium prussian blue//activated carbon cell.8Bi H. Wang X. Liu H. He Y. Wang W. Deng W. Ma X. Wang Y. Rao W. Chai Y. et al.A Universal Approach to Aqueous Energy Storage via Ultralow-Cost Electrolyte with Super-Concentrated Sugar as Hydrogen-Bond-Regulated Solute.Adv. Mater. 2020; 32: e2000074Crossref PubMed Scopus (23) Google Scholar The molecular crowding is Li4Ti5O12//LiMn2O4 cell in an electrolyte of 2 m LiTFSI–94%PEG–6%H2O.9Xie J. Liang Z. Lu Y.C. Molecular Crowding Electrolytes for High-Voltage Aqueous Batteries.Nat. Mater. 2020; https://doi.org/10.1038/s41563-41020-40667-yCrossref Google Scholar The passivation can be observed in Al2O3-coated Al and TiO2-coated Ti current collectors in 15 m NaClO4 electrolyte.10Hou Z. Zhang X. Ao H. Liu M. Zhu Y. Qian Y. Passivation Effect for Current Collectors Enables High-Voltage Aqueous Sodium Ion Batteries.Mater. Today Energy. 2019; 14: 100337Crossref Scopus (20) Google Scholar The pH-decoupling was achieved with ion-selective membrane in alkaline Zn/Zn(OH)42– and acidic MnO2/Mn2+ dual-electrolyte system.11Chao D. Ye C. Xie F. Zhou W. Zhang Q. Gu Q. Davey K. Gu L. Qiao S.-Z. Atomic Engineering Catalyzed MnO2 Electrolysis Kinetics for a Hybrid Aqueous Battery with High Power and Energy Density.Adv. Mater. 2020; 32: e2001894Crossref PubMed Scopus (65) Google Scholar,12Liu C. Chi X. Han Q. Liu Y. A High Energy Density Aqueous Battery Achieved by Dual Dissolution/Deposition Reactions Separated in Acid-Alkaline Electrolyte.Adv. Energy Mater. 2020; 10: 1903589Crossref Scopus (31) Google ScholarView Large Image Figure ViewerDownload Hi-res image Download (PPT) (Left) Redox potentials of available redox couples that may be suitable for new ABs with extended ESW. (Right) The competitive redox couples refer to Zn/Zn2+ and MnO2/Mn2+ redox couples at anode and cathode, respectively, in 1 mol/L ZnSO4 + 1 mol/L MnSO4 electrolyte.7Chao D. Zhou W. Ye C. Zhang Q. Chen Y. Gu L. Davey K. Qiao S.Z. An Electrolytic Zn-MnO2 Battery for High-Voltage and Scalable Energy Storage.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2019; 58: 7823-7828Crossref PubMed Scopus (301) Google Scholar The “water-in-salt” corresponds to a super-concentrated solute of 21 m LiTFSI electrolyte in Mo6S8//LiMn2O4 cell4Suo L. Borodin O. Gao T. Olguin M. Ho J. Fan X. et al.“Water-in-Salt” Electrolyte Enables High-Voltage Aqueous Lithium-Ion Chemistries.Science. 2015; 350: 938-943Crossref PubMed Scopus (1278) Google Scholar or super-concentrated solute of sugar in sodium prussian blue//activated carbon cell.8Bi H. Wang X. Liu H. He Y. Wang W. Deng W. Ma X. Wang Y. Rao W. Chai Y. et al.A Universal Approach to Aqueous Energy Storage via Ultralow-Cost Electrolyte with Super-Concentrated Sugar as Hydrogen-Bond-Regulated Solute.Adv. Mater. 2020; 32: e2000074Crossref PubMed Scopus (23) Google Scholar The molecular crowding is Li4Ti5O12//LiMn2O4 cell in an electrolyte of 2 m LiTFSI–94%PEG–6%H2O.9Xie J. Liang Z. Lu Y.C. Molecular Crowding Electrolytes for High-Voltage Aqueous Batteries.Nat. Mater. 2020; https://doi.org/10.1038/s41563-41020-40667-yCrossref Google Scholar The passivation can be observed in Al2O3-coated Al and TiO2-coated Ti current collectors in 15 m NaClO4 electrolyte.10Hou Z. Zhang X. Ao H. Liu M. Zhu Y. Qian Y. Passivation Effect for Current Collectors Enables High-Voltage Aqueous Sodium Ion Batteries.Mater. Today Energy. 2019; 14: 100337Crossref Scopus (20) Google Scholar The pH-decoupling was achieved with ion-selective membrane in alkaline Zn/Zn(OH)42– and acidic MnO2/Mn2+ dual-electrolyte system.11Chao D. Ye C. Xie F. Zhou W. Zhang Q. Gu Q. Davey K. Gu L. Qiao S.-Z. Atomic Engineering Catalyzed MnO2 Electrolysis Kinetics for a Hybrid Aqueous Battery with High Power and Energy Density.Adv. Mater. 2020; 32: e2001894Crossref PubMed Scopus (65) Google Scholar,12Liu C. Chi X. Han Q. Liu Y. A High Energy Density Aqueous Battery Achieved by Dual Dissolution/Deposition Reactions Separated in Acid-Alkaline Electrolyte.Adv. Energy Mater. 2020; 10: 1903589Crossref Scopus (31) Google Scholar Some relatively cheap non-fluorinated solutes such as sodium perchlorate (NaClO4), zinc chloride (ZnCl2), lithium acetate (CH3COOLi), and potassium acetate (CH3COOK) have been explored recently.1Chao D. Zhou W. Xie F. Ye C. Li H. Jaroniec M. Qiao S.-Z. Roadmap for Advanced Aqueous Batteries: From Design of Materials to Applications.Sci. Adv. 2020; 6: eaba4098Crossref PubMed Scopus (180) Google Scholar,2Liu Z. Huang Y. Huang Y. Yang Q. Li X. Huang Z. et al.Voltage Issue of Aqueous Rechargeable Metal-Ion Batteries.Chem. Soc. Rev. 2020; 49: 180-232Crossref PubMed Google Scholar Super-concentrated sugar as a low-cost hydrogen-bond-regulated solute is proven effective in extending the ESW up to ∼2.8 V.8Bi H. Wang X. Liu H. He Y. Wang W. Deng W. Ma X. Wang Y. Rao W. Chai Y. et al.A Universal Approach to Aqueous Energy Storage via Ultralow-Cost Electrolyte with Super-Concentrated Sugar as Hydrogen-Bond-Regulated Solute.Adv. Mater. 2020; 32: e2000074Crossref PubMed Scopus (23) Google Scholar Although sugar is naturally inert in the electrolyte, the SCE with sugar solute is effective in reducing the free water molecules, destroying the tetrahedral structure, and breaking the hydrogen bonds of water molecules. In addition to solutes, it is also possible to stabilize the aqueous electrolyte by passivating the current collectors. Hou et al.10Hou Z. Zhang X. Ao H. Liu M. Zhu Y. Qian Y. Passivation Effect for Current Collectors Enables High-Voltage Aqueous Sodium Ion Batteries.Mater. Today Energy. 2019; 14: 100337Crossref Scopus (20) Google Scholar found that films of Al2O3 at the cathode and TiO2 at the anode current collectors exhibit an evident passivation effect which increases the energy barrier of water splitting. By regulating the thickness of oxide films and the concentration of the WIS electrolyte, an ESW of ∼3.5 V is achieved in a full cell coupling TiS2//Prussian blue in a relatively high concentration of 15 m NaClO4 aqueous electrolyte (Figure 3). Despite the great success in widening ESW from high-concentration solutes, the high viscosity and desolvation energy, decreased wettability, and therefore longer wetting (electrode stack infiltration) time of the SCEs further complicates the structure and assembly of ABs in their practical applications. Hence, the large-scale application of SCEs has been beset. Other strategies to achieve wide ESW with low-cost and moderate solute concentrations are urgently needed. In addition to solutes, engineering the solvent also provides new opportunities. Recently, Lu and coworkers reported a molecular crowding electrolyte with a low solute concentration of 2 m LiTFSI in a mixed solvent of 94% poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) and 6% H2O.9Xie J. Liang Z. Lu Y.C. Molecular Crowding Electrolytes for High-Voltage Aqueous Batteries.Nat. Mater. 2020; https://doi.org/10.1038/s41563-41020-40667-yCrossref Google Scholar Using the conventional electrode materials, the constructed Li4Ti5O12//LiMn2O4 cell shows an ESW of 3.2 V via confining water molecules in a crowding agent of PEG network through hydrogen bonding. The PEG solvent is water-miscible, non-toxic, inert, and inexpensive. Different from previous WIS solute SCE, electrolyte with a molecular crowding solvent endows a lower solution density of ca. 1.10 g cm–3 than that of the 21 m LiTFSI WIS electrolyte (ca. 1.65 g cm–3) and the Li(TFSI)0.7(BETI)0.3 hydrate melt electrolyte (ca. 1.78 g cm–3). Hence, this adds benefit to the gravimetric energy density when the total weight of all cell components is counted. This work offers a new avenue to enlarge the ESW especially by suppressing HER and broadens the choice of negative electrode materials (Figure 3). Nevertheless, there are also shortfalls of this new low-solute and high-solvent concentration electrolyte. First, the water-retaining property and electric/ionic conductivity need to be further improved to demonstrate its viability in high-rate and long-cycling energy storage applications. Another drawback of this work is its limited gravimetric cell capacity of less than 50 mAh g–1, which is confined by the theoretical capacity of electrodes for both Li4Ti5O12 (175 mAh g–1) and LiMn2O4 (148 mAh g–1). Hopefully this is not an intrinsic limitation and can be mitigated by choosing concomitant high-capacity and high-voltage redox couples. From the perspective of electrodes, introduction of competitive redox couples that show faster kinetics than those of HER or OER is considered a feasible approach to enhance both the output voltage and the capacity of ABs. As sketched in Figure 3, suitable candidates of the redox couples should exhibit high potential for cathode, such as Ce3+/Ce4+ (1.74 V versus standard hydrogen potential [SHE]), Mn2+/Mn3+ (1.54 V versus SHE) and Mn2+/MnO2 (1.23 V versus SHE), or low potential for the anode, such as Zn(OH)42–/Zn (–1.21 V versus SHE) and Zn2+/Zn (–0.76 V versus SHE). Recently, we introduced a high-voltage redox couple of Mn2+/MnO2 (Figure 3) in conventional Zn-ion battery via a facile tuning of the proton activity.7Chao D. Zhou W. Ye C. Zhang Q. Chen Y. Gu L. Davey K. Qiao S.Z. An Electrolytic Zn-MnO2 Battery for High-Voltage and Scalable Energy Storage.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 2019; 58: 7823-7828Crossref PubMed Scopus (301) Google Scholar Without using the SCEs with concentrated solutes or solvents, the electrolytic Zn-MnO2 system presents an ultra-flat output voltage as high as 1.95 V in a low-cost and LCE (1 mol/L ZnSO4 + 1 mol/L MnSO4). The voltage is significantly higher than that of conventional Zn//Mn battery (1.2–1.4 V). The ESW of the electrolytic Zn-MnO2 system in LCE can be further widened from 2.4 V to 3.5 V when an ion-selective membrane and more negative redox couple of alkaline Zn(OH)42–/Zn were incorporated (Figure 3).11Chao D. Ye C. Xie F. Zhou W. Zhang Q. Gu Q. Davey K. Gu L. Qiao S.-Z. Atomic Engineering Catalyzed MnO2 Electrolysis Kinetics for a Hybrid Aqueous Battery with High Power and Energy Density.Adv. Mater. 2020; 32: e2001894Crossref PubMed Scopus (65) Google Scholar,12Liu C. Chi X. Han Q. Liu Y. A High Energy Density Aqueous Battery Achieved by Dual Dissolution/Deposition Reactions Separated in Acid-Alkaline Electrolyte.Adv. Energy Mater. 2020; 10: 1903589Crossref Scopus (31) Google Scholar The rationale behind it is that the redox potentials of HER and OER are pH-dependent. Hence, according to the Pourbaix diagrams, individual control in the pH of catholyte and anolyte by ion-selective membranes are possible. In addition to high output voltage, given the high theoretical capacity from both Zn anode (820 mAh g–1) and Mn cathode (616 mAh g–1), a high gravimetric cell capacity of ∼270 mAh g–1 can be achieved on the basis of the total weight of positive and negative active materials.11Chao D. Ye C. Xie F. Zhou W. Zhang Q. Gu Q. Davey K. Gu L. Qiao S.-Z. Atomic Engineering Catalyzed MnO2 Electrolysis Kinetics for a Hybrid Aqueous Battery with High Power and Energy Density.Adv. Mater. 2020; 32: e2001894Crossref PubMed Scopus (65) Google Scholar On one hand, the usage of an ion-selective membrane, such as anion/cation exchange membranes and bipolar membrane, will activate most of the cathode and anode redox couples and broaden the ESW of ABs. On the other, addition of membranes complicates the battery structure and poses extra challenges on battery assembly, welding, and housing. It should also be noted that, although the issues of cost and kinetics in SCEs can be eliminated in LCEs, the anodic dissolution and side reaction problems of the anode materials, cathode materials, or current collectors may be critical in achieving ultrastable aqueous energy storage in diluted systems. To conclude, the fast progress in rechargeable ABs is encouraging and exciting. A rational choice and integration strategies from electrolytes, redox couples, membranes, and current collector materials will endow not only affordable high-voltage aqueous batteries but also high energy and power densities. Although significant advances have been made in this area, unremitting efforts are still required to meet the practical metrics for the next stage development of ABs. In the future design of high-voltage ABs, below directions are believed to have potential.1.Exploring new competitive redox couples in LCEs that are stable, highly reversible, and of faster reaction kinetics compared with that of OER/HER, such as solving the reversibility problem of the ultra-high voltage redox couple of MnO4–/Mn2+ (1.51 V versus SHE) and ultra-low voltage redox couple of Al3+/Al (–1.66 V versus SHE).2.Developing untouched high capacity electrode materials in novel SCEs that are affordable and of high specific energy, such as low-cost solutes of NaClO4, LiCH3COO, KCH3COO, ZnCl2 and sugar; solvents of poly(ethylene glycol) and succinonitrile; and high capacity redox couples of S6/S2− or S/S2−.3.Inventing novel low-cost electrolytes with suppressed water activity and density, by, for example, using lightweight molecular crowding solvent and hydrous salts directly with/without solvents.4.Manipulating the interfacial reactions on cathode, anode, current collector, and separator to fundamentally understand the voltage widening mechanisms.5.Optimizing the device design in pH-decoupling ABs and constructing relevant membranes with low-cost and high ion selectivity.6.Evaluating the performances of ABs in a more practical metric, such as at high gravimetrical and volumetrical loadings, with starved electrolyte-based device design and the transient power release, self-discharge, and wide-temperature performances. Financial supports from the Australian Research Council through Discovery Projects ( FL170100154 and DE200101244 ) are appreciated.