Auditing AI for Whom? A Community-Centric Approach to Rebuilding Public Trust in Singapore

Wenxi Zhang,Sharanya Shanmugam,Jason G Allen,Willow Wong,Olivia Xu,Willow anon
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4698703
2024-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:With the extensive use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in smart cities, ethical and legal concerns regarding the design and deployment of these emerging technologies have arisen globally. In addressing these concerns, many current regulatory efforts are led by back-end technicians and ‘expert’ decision makers, insufficiently including everyday users. Against this backdrop, this report proposes an audit framework for AI technologies that focuses on the post-deployment downstream impacts of AI in community spaces – with direct input from community users themselves. We explore how the “community-centric” approach can potentially close the loop between internal and external audit, and call for AI auditors to possess a range of hard and soft skills that enable them to communicate input from community members to internal audit teams, so that technologies can be designed with community perspectives in mind. This report offers a unique Asian/Singaporean perspective to the regulation of AI technologies. In contrast to Western-centric regulatory frameworks that tend to focus on individual rights and freedoms, we suggest that Asian cultures prioritise collective understandings of benefit and harm, which supports the implementation of community-centric AI audits as a way to promote trust building in a smart city. This report also aims to present the findings from a roundtable discussion exploring the feasibility of community-centric AI audits conducted with experts in Singapore that work closely with AI technologies, AI governance or auditing. While a range of practical considerations and potential challenges, such as the difficulties of promoting the audit of technologies to local tech companies, was raised, there ultimately remains optimism and significance in the endeavour.This Research Project was conducted by the Centre for AI and Data Governance (CAIDG) based at Singapore Management University (SMU) and was supported by The Notre Dame-IBM Tech Ethics Lab.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?