Teaching Ethics in Criminal Justice to First Year Law Students: Or Efforts to Dislodge the CSI Effect

S. Rutberg

Abstract:This article discusses the implementation of an innovative first year course at Golden Gate University School of Law entitled “Lawyering Skills: Ethics in Criminal Justice.” The course, offered for the first time in the spring of 2011, was the product of curricular reform set in motion by the 2007 Carnegie Foundation Report, Educating Lawyers: Preparation for the Profession of Law. Golden Gate University has had a longtime focus both on practical legal education and ethical training. We devote a substantial portion of our resources to clinical programs and simulation courses. These opportunities, however, are generally only available to students in their second or third years. In assessing the import of the Carnegie Report, our faculty focused on the Report’s critique of the traditional first year. In particular, we sought a “counterbalance” to help students bridge the gap between theory and practice early in their legal education. Thus the creation of a seminar style Lawyering elective, required in the first year. My course, Ethics in Criminal Justice, was one of twelve offered. These courses were designed with several overarching goals: an emphasis on skills and values, and the integration of ethics and professionalism. Beyond these general principles, I had personal goals of my own. As a longtime public defender, and former director of a law school innocence project, I wanted to dispel the myths and stereotypes about criminal practice generated by popular culture. Further, I wanted students considering a career in criminal justice to understand the complexities of the practice; to recognize the necessity of cultural literacy; and to comprehend the risk of miscarriages of justice inherent when prosecutors or defense attorneys make even “minor” compromises to their ethical obligations. In the end, although my goals of inspiring “best practices” of prosecutors and defense attorneys proved difficult to measure, I write this article to share aspects which were effective and the lessons I learned in how to make such a course more successful. This article begins with the process that led the law school to provide an elective for first year students and the faculty collaboration in developing the menu of elective courses. In the second section, I discuss my background in the criminal justice system and the goals which drove the design of this simulation based lawyering course with a focus on ethical criminal practice. Next the article examines how I implemented the course, and the challenges I encountered teaching the elective for the first time. Finally, the article concludes with lessons I learned from this experience as I prepare to teach the course for a second time. [1] @ Susan Rutberg 2011

Political Science,Law