Cl. Gabriel,Ph. Spindel,S. Massar,R. Parentani
Abstract:We compute the transition amplitudes between charged particles of mass $M$ and $m$ accelerated by a constant electric field and interacting by the exchange of quanta of a third field. We work in second quantization in order to take into account both recoil effects induced by transitions and the vacuum instability of the charged fields. In spite of both effects, when the exchanged particle is neutral, the equilibrium ratio of the populations is simply $\exp(\pi (M^2 - m^2)/eE)$. Thus, in the limit $(M-m)/M \to 0$, one recovers Unruh's result characterized by the temperature $a/2\pi$ where $a$ is the acceleration. When the exchanged particle is charged, its vacuum instability prevents a simple description of the equilibrium state. However, in the limit wherein the charge of the exchanged particle tends to zero, the equilibrium distribution is once more Boltzmanian, but characterized not only by a temperature but also by the electric potential felt by the exchanged particle. This work therefore confirms that thermodynamics in the presence of horizons does not rely on a semi-classical treatment. The relationship with thermodymanics of charged black holes is stressed.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the relationship between charged particles interacting in a constant electric field and the Unruh effect. Specifically, the authors explored the following issues:
1. **Behavior of charged particles in an electric field**: Study the accelerated motion of charged particles (with masses \(M\) and \(m\) respectively) in a constant electric field and interact by exchanging the quanta of a third field.
2. **Calculation of transition amplitudes**: Calculate the probability amplitudes of these charged particles transitioning in the electric field, taking into account the recoil effect and the vacuum instability of the charged field.
3. **Thermodynamic equilibrium distribution**: Analyze the thermodynamic equilibrium distribution of these particle systems under different conditions, especially the differences when the exchanged particles are neutral and charged.
4. **Verification of the Unruh effect**: Verify whether the results of the Unruh effect can be recovered in the limit case when the exchanged particles are neutral, that is, the temperature is \(\frac{a}{2\pi}\) (where \(a\) is the acceleration).
5. **Influence of charged - particle exchange**: When the exchanged particles are charged, how does their vacuum instability affect the equilibrium - state description of the system? In particular, when the charge amount tends to zero, does the equilibrium distribution of the system still conform to the Boltzmann distribution and is jointly determined by temperature and electric potential?
### Specific problems
- **Transition rate and equilibrium distribution**: When the exchanged particles are neutral, the equilibrium distribution of the system can be expressed in a simple exponential form:
\[
\frac{R_{m \to M}}{R_{M \to m}} = e^{-\pi(M^2 - m^2)/eE}
\]
This indicates that in some limit conditions, the results of the Unruh effect can be recovered.
- **Case of charged - particle exchange**: When the exchanged particles are charged, the equilibrium distribution of the system is no longer simply described by the Boltzmann ratio, but requires the introduction of additional parameters, such as the electric potential difference:
\[
\frac{R_{m \to M}}{R_{M \to m}} = e^{-2\pi (\Delta M - \alpha E / 2\bar{a}) / \bar{a}}
\]
where \(\alpha\) is the charge of the exchanged particles, \(\bar{a}\) is the acceleration, and \(\Delta M\) is the mass difference.
### Conclusion
Through detailed calculations and analyses, this paper confirms the behavior of charged particles in an electric field and their relationship with the Unruh effect, especially the influence on the thermodynamic equilibrium distribution when considering charged - particle exchange. In addition, it also explores the analogical relationship between these results and the thermodynamics of charged black holes.