Two non-orthogonal states can be cloned by a unitary-reduction process

Lu-Ming Duan,Guang-Can Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/9704020

1997-04-10

Abstract:We show that, there are physical means for cloning two non-orthogonal pure states which are secretly chosen from a certain set $% \$={ | \Psi_0 > , | \Psi_1 > }$. The states are cloned through a unitary evolution together with a measurement. The cloning efficiency can not attain 100%. With some negative measurement results, the cloning fails.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to clone two non - orthogonal quantum pure states by physical means**.

### Background and Problem Elaboration

According to the basic principles of quantum mechanics, an unknown quantum state cannot be precisely copied, which is known as the Quantum No - Cloning Theorem. This principle is of great significance in quantum information theory, especially in the field of quantum cryptography. However, the Quantum No - Cloning Theorem was initially only applicable to cases of at least three quantum states and was mainly proved based on unitary evolution. Therefore, for the question of whether two non - orthogonal quantum states can be cloned, previous theories did not completely rule out this possibility.

### Core Contributions of the Paper

The author of this paper shows that by combining **unitary evolution and measurement**, there do exist physical means to clone two non - orthogonal pure states. Specifically, the author proposes a theorem, indicating that if given two non - orthogonal quantum states \( |\Psi_0\rangle \) and \( |\Psi_1\rangle \), through appropriate unitary evolution \( U \) and measurement \( M \), the following evolutions can be achieved:

\[
|\Psi_0\rangle |\Sigma\rangle \xrightarrow{U+M} |\Psi_0\rangle |\Psi_0\rangle,
\]
\[
|\Psi_1\rangle |\Sigma\rangle \xrightarrow{U+M} |\Psi_1\rangle |\Psi_1\rangle,
\]

where \( |\Sigma\rangle \) is the input state of the auxiliary system B, and systems A and B have n - dimensional Hilbert spaces respectively.

### Cloning Efficiency and Security

Although two non - orthogonal states can be cloned by the above method, the cloning success rate cannot reach 100%. The paper also proves that for any cloning machine, the cloning efficiencies \( \eta_0 \) and \( \eta_1 \) must satisfy certain basic inequalities, for example:

\[
\frac{\eta_0 + \eta_1}{2} \leq \frac{1 - \langle \Psi_0 | \Psi_1 \rangle}{1 - \langle \Psi_0 | \Psi_1 \rangle^2 \langle m_0 | m_1 \rangle} \leq \frac{1}{1 + \langle \Psi_0 | \Psi_1 \rangle}.
\]

This means that even if non - orthogonal states can be cloned, the success rate is always lower than 100%, thus ensuring the security of quantum cryptosystems based on non - orthogonal states. In fact, the security of quantum cryptography does not depend on the non - cloneability of non - orthogonal states, but on the fact that the cloning efficiency cannot reach 100%.

### Conclusion

This paper solves the problem of whether two non - orthogonal quantum states can be cloned and proposes a method of combining unitary evolution and measurement to achieve this goal. At the same time, the paper also discusses the limitations of cloning efficiency and its significance for the security of quantum cryptography.