LPG, Gasoline, and Diesel Engines for Small Marine Vessels: A Comparative Analysis of Eco-Friendliness and Economic Feasibility

Jeong Kuk Kim,Siljung Yeo,Jae-Hyuk Choi,Won-Ju Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17020450

IF: 3.2

2024-01-18

Energies

Abstract:As an escalating global concern for environmentally sustainable marine fuels, liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) is attracting attention as an eco-friendly and economical alternative. This study explored LPG utilization in small marine vessels, focusing on its eco-friendliness and economic feasibility. To assess its environmental implications, the AVL FIRE simulation program was used to compare CO2, CO, NO, and soot emissions from LPG engines with those from conventional gasoline and diesel engines. The LPG engine model relied on data from a pioneering type-approved experimental LPG engine designed for small South Korean marine vessels, while parameters for gasoline and diesel engines were adjusted to suit their distinctive features. Regarding long-term economic feasibility, assuming a 30-year ship lifespan, incorporating 2022 annual average prices, average annual price growth rates, and annual fuel consumption data of each fuel, results indicate that LPG engines exhibited lower CO2, CO, NO, and soot emissions than conventional engines, except that NO emissions were higher than gasoline engines. Evaluating LPG's economic feasibility over a 30-year ship life cycle for an individual vessel revealed varying fuel cost savings, with the greatest savings observed in gasoline–other (KRW 2220.7 million) and the least in gasoline–coastal (KRW 1152.5 million). These findings offer vital insights for ship operators and policymakers seeking a balance between eco-friendliness and cost-effectiveness, as well as LPG engine technology emerging as pivotal for a sustainable future, harmonizing environmental protection and economic viability.

energy & fuels

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the environmental protection and economic feasibility of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) engines on small marine vessels. Specifically, the research aims to:

1. **Compare the emissions of different fuel engines**: By using the AVL FIRE simulation program, compare the differences in carbon dioxide (\( \text{CO}_2 \)), carbon monoxide (\( \text{CO} \)), nitrogen oxides (\( \text{NO}_x \)) and soot emissions between LPG engines and traditional gasoline and diesel engines.

- **Formula representation**:
- Carbon dioxide emission amount: \( \text{CO}_2 \)
- Carbon monoxide emission amount: \( \text{CO} \)
- Nitrogen oxides emission amount: \( \text{NO}_x \)
- Soot emission amount: soot

2. **Long - term economic feasibility analysis**: Based on the 30 - year ship life cycle, considering the annual average price in 2022, the average annual price growth rate and the annual fuel consumption data, evaluate the economic advantages of LPG engines over gasoline and diesel engines.

- **Formula representation**:
- Economic feasibility calculation formula: \[ \text{Total cost}=\sum_{t = 1}^{T}(\text{Fuel cost}_t+\text{Maintenance cost}_t+\text{Other cost}_t) \]
- Where \( T \) represents the time period (such as 30 years), \(\text{Fuel cost}_t\) is the fuel cost in the \( t \) - th year, \(\text{Maintenance cost}_t\) is the maintenance cost in the \( t \) - th year, and \(\text{Other cost}_t\) includes other related costs.

The research results show that LPG engines show better environmental protection in most emission indicators and have significant economic advantages in some cases. These findings provide important references for shipowners and policymakers, helping them find a balance between environmental protection and economic benefits, and at the same time promoting the development of LPG engine technology to achieve the goal of sustainable development.