Abstract:Across species and environments, the ribosome content of cell populations correlates with population growth rate. The robustness and universality of this correlation have led to its classification as a growth law. This law has fueled theories about how evolution selects for microbial organisms that maximize their growth rate based on nutrient availability, and it has informed models about how individual cells regulate their growth rates and ribosomal content. However, due to methodological limitations, this growth law has rarely been studied at the level of individual cells. While populations of fast-growing cells tend to have more ribosomes than populations of slow-growing cells, it is unclear whether individual cells tightly regulate their ribosome content to match their environment. Here, we employ recent groundbreaking single-cell RNA sequencing techniques to study this growth law at the single-cell level in two different microbes, S. cerevisiae (a single-celled yeast and eukaryote) and B. subtilis (a bacterium and prokaryote). In both species, we observe significant variation in the ribosomal content of single cells that is not predictive of growth rate. Fast-growing populations include cells exhibiting transcriptional signatures of slow growth and stress, as do cells with the highest ribosome content we survey. Broadening our focus to non-ribosomal transcripts reveals subpopulations of cells in unique transcriptional states suggestive that they have evolved to do things other than maximize their rate of growth. Overall, these results indicate that single-cell ribosome levels are not finely tuned to match population growth rates or nutrient availability and cannot be predicted by a Gaussian process model that assumes measurements are sampled from a normal distribution centered on the population average. This work encourages the expansion of growth law and other models that predict how growth rates are regulated or how they evolve to consider single-cell heterogeneity. To this end, we provide extensive data and analysis of ribosomal and transcriptomic variation across thousands of single cells from multiple conditions, replicates, and species.

From single-cell variability to population growth

From noisy cell size control to population growth: when variability can be beneficial

The Effects of Stochasticity at the Single-Cell Level and Cell Size Control on the Population Growth

Cell Size Regulation Induces Sustained Oscillations in the Population Growth Rate

Fluctuations in growth rates determine the generation time and size distributions of E. coli cells

Non-genetic variability: survival strategy or nuisance?

Single-cell Growth Rate Variability in Balanced Exponential Growth

Individuality and universality in the growth-division laws of single E. coli cells

Cell Population Growth Kinetics in the Presence of Stochastic Heterogeneity of Cell Phenotype

Inferring Population Dynamics from Single-Cell RNA-sequencing Time Series Data.

Single-cell heterogeneity in ribosome content and the consequences for the growth laws

Asymptotic decoupling of population growth rate and cell size distribution

Quantifying gene expression variability arising from randomness in cell division times

Intrinsic and extrinsic noise of gene expression in lineage trees

Bridging the time scales of single-cell and population dynamics

Scaling Laws Governing Stochastic Growth and Division of Single Bacterial Cells

Stochasticity of metabolism and growth at the single-cell level

Gene expression in growing cells: A biophysical primer

Signal in the noise: temporal variation in exponentially growing populations

Competition between transient oscillations and early stochasticity in exponentially growing populations

Inheritance and variability of kinetic gene expression parameters in microbial cells: modeling and inference from lineage tree data